[IFWP] BOUNCE list@ifwp.org: Non-member submission from [Jim Dixon jdd@vbc.net]

2000-09-18 Thread Richard J. Sexton
(fixed) Date: Mon, 18 Sep 2000 07:35:11 +0100 (BST) From: Jim Dixon [EMAIL PROTECTED] X-Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: IFWP [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Lawrence Lessig [EMAIL PROTECTED], Gordon Cook [EMAIL PROTECTED], Domain Policy [EMAIL PROTECTED], AWPD [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject:

Re: [DOMAIN-POLICY] [IFWP] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Jim Dixon
On Mon, 18 Sep 2000, Richard J. Sexton wrote: [Lessig:] But second, and more to the point, I know first hand what lead to the end of the IFWP process, as I was part of the negotiations in that process. Of all the "parties" in that negotiation, Berkman was the last pushing for the

Re: [DOMAIN-POLICY] [IFWP] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Dan Steinberg
Although Jim and I had many differences of opinion both on the desired result and how to get there I have to agree with his version of history. But Singapore was a long time ago. I think what we are doing here is finger-pointing. What good is it to asssign blame now? I dont see it changing

Re: [DOMAIN-POLICY] [IFWP] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Jim Dixon
On Mon, 18 Sep 2000, Dan Steinberg wrote: Although Jim and I had many differences of opinion both on the desired result and how to get there I have to agree with his version of history. But Singapore was a long time ago. I think what we are doing here is finger-pointing. What good is it to

Re: [DOMAIN-POLICY] [IFWP] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Richard J. Sexton
At 03:14 PM 9/18/00 +0100, Jim Dixon wrote: On Mon, 18 Sep 2000, Dan Steinberg wrote: Although Jim and I had many differences of opinion both on the desired result and how to get there I have to agree with his version of history. But Singapore was a long time ago. I think what we are doing

Re: [DOMAIN-POLICY] [IFWP] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Ellen Rony
FWIW: the minutes of the final two meetings of the IFWP Steering Committee (September 3 and 5, 1998) are still posted at http://www.domainhandbook.com/scmin.html One has to wonder why so few people (particularly Sims, Frankel, Roberts, Magaziner) were able to wield so much power over what was

[IFWP] Re: [awpd] Re: Where Does Lessig Stand?

2000-09-18 Thread Jay Fenello
At 03:11 PM 9/16/00, Lawrence Lessig wrote: First, as I would have thought obvious, there is something more than bizarre about the idea that in the mix of actors in the initial formation of ICANN -- representatives of the most powerful government in the world, the most powerful corporations in