[IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN

1999-09-11 Thread Greg Skinner
Ellen Rony [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mr, Farber. There is room here for a different cause/effect analysis. I posit that if ICANN fails, it will be an indicator that the ICANN *model* was not workable, NOT that the Net cannot manage itself. The model that is the source of so much controversy

Re: [IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN

1999-09-11 Thread Richard J. Sexton
At 10:30 AM 9/11/99 -0700, you wrote: Ellen Rony [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mr, Farber. There is room here for a different cause/effect analysis. I posit that if ICANN fails, it will be an indicator that the ICANN *model* was not workable, NOT that the Net cannot manage itself. The model that

Re: [IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN

1999-09-11 Thread Ray Hallman
M Subject: [IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN Ellen Rony [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Mr, Farber. There is room here for a different cause/effect analysis. I posit that if ICANN fails, it will be an indicator that the ICANN *model

Re: [IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN

1999-09-11 Thread Jeff Williams
Richard, Ellen and all, As Ellen indicates, and I think correctly, governments can intervene at nearly any juncture in any effort of self regulation and influence or force their will upon the process. The GAC was set up primarily by the ICANN (Initial?) Interim board to circumvent this

[IFWP] Re: November Cook Report - intro and part 1 ISOC's critical rolein enabling ICANN

1999-09-10 Thread David Farber
Gordon, My only comment is I wish the "unindicted conspirators" were as devious and organized as you claim. My experience is that they were not and still are not. I just don't believe that the ICANN Board (nor did the ITAG or the ISOC Board) meets in private to plot the takeover of the