Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-09 Thread Paul Gear
On 09/07/12 06:01, Chris Buechler wrote: ... Can anyone comment on the quality of the Broadcom driver in post-8.1 releases? Is there any way to run a more recent kernel in conjunction with pfSense? Short of running 2.1, not easily. I do have some customer systems running 2.1 in

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-08 Thread Chris Buechler
On Sat, Jul 7, 2012 at 3:26 AM, Paul Gear p...@gear.dyndns.org wrote: On 07/07/12 14:33, Adam Van Ornum wrote: FreeBSD's driver apparently is much improved in later releases (remember, pfSense is based on 7.3, which is quite a few years old now), so it's just a matter of waiting until

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-07 Thread Paul Gear
On 07/07/12 14:33, Adam Van Ornum wrote: FreeBSD's driver apparently is much improved in later releases (remember, pfSense is based on 7.3, which is quite a few years old now), so it's just a matter of waiting until pfSense 2.1(???) comes out, based on FreeBSD 8, or 9, or whatever the next

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-06 Thread Paul Gear
On 29/06/12 11:07, Paul Gear wrote: ... Server hardware: IBM x3550, Xeon E5405 2 GHz, 2 GB RAM, 2 x 300 GB 10K RPM SAS HD in hardware RAID 1, 2 x Broadcom NetXtreme II BCM5708 1000Base-T (B2) ... Hope that all makes sense. My gut/experience tells me this is a NIC driver bug/deficiency.

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-06 Thread Adam Thompson
It's disappointing that FreeBSD's Broadcom drivers are so far behind VMware Linux - is there anything we can do (as non-kernel hackers) to help get this very common chipset well-supported? Would throwing some $$$ at a pfSense or FreeBSD developer be useful? FreeBSD's driver apparently is

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-07-06 Thread Adam Van Ornum
FreeBSD's driver apparently is much improved in later releases (remember, pfSense is based on 7.3, which is quite a few years old now), so it's just a matter of waiting until pfSense 2.1(???) comes out, based on FreeBSD 8, or 9, or whatever the next evolutionary step is. For what it's

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-29 Thread Adam Thompson
You're largely correct, pfSense has - sometimes - issues with Broadcom NICs. If you search the mailing list archives and the bug tracker you'll see a number of reports/complaints. Many of these issues have been fixed since the 1.x era, but there are still occasional compatibility issues. The NIC

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-29 Thread jerome alet
Hi, From: Adam Thompson athom...@athompso.net You're largely correct, pfSense has - sometimes - issues with Broadcom NICs. If you search the mailing list archives and the bug tracker you'll see a number of reports/complaints. Many of these issues

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-29 Thread Vick Khera
On Thu, Jun 28, 2012 at 9:07 PM, Paul Gear p...@gear.dyndns.org wrote: Server hardware: IBM x3550, Xeon E5405 2 GHz, 2 GB RAM, 2 x 300 GB 10K RPM SAS HD in hardware RAID 1, 2 x Broadcom NetXtreme II BCM5708 1000Base-T (B2) About two weeks ago I had to put into production a temporary hacked

[pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-28 Thread Paul Gear
Hi all, I'm testing pfSense for a client, looking to put it into an existing production network some time in the next month or two. (Some background at [1], if anyone cares...) In terms of features and interface it is a win, but we're having massive problems with stability that seem to be

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-28 Thread Chris Buechler
On Thu, Jun 28, 2012 at 9:07 PM, Paul Gear p...@gear.dyndns.org wrote: Hi all, I'm testing pfSense for a client, looking to put it into an existing production network some time in the next month or two.  (Some background at [1], if anyone cares...)  In terms of features and interface it is a

Re: [pfSense] Network freezes on IBM x3550, Broadcom NICs

2012-06-28 Thread David Burgess
On Thu, Jun 28, 2012 at 10:11 PM, Paul Gear p...@gear.dyndns.org wrote: What should be my next troubleshooting step? memtest? Different NICs? Have you looked at your MBUF usage (netstat -m)? I get similar symptoms after running out of MBUFs, but if you followed the first step in the doc you