Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting James Linder : > Can your monitor resolve 16 vs 24 colour? maybe but maybe not. Almost definitely, unless it's a really old LCD one. You can see the difference even from the default LDM login screen. At 16-bit, the blue background is noticeably barred with distinct colour bands. > Th

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread James Linder
On 26/03/2012, at 7:07 PM, ltsp-discuss-requ...@lists.sourceforge.net wrote: >> By default, X_COLOR_DEPTH is 32 for thin clients, which means that a >> 320x240 youtube video needs 73.728.000 bps bandwidth (30 fps, 32 bpp). >> >> Setting X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 for thin clients makes that video need exa

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
Στις 26/03/2012 08:25 μμ, ο/η Alkis Georgopoulos έγραψε: > After some IRC discussion, here's what will be implemented: > ... Sorry, some code paths depended on X_COLOR_DEPTH being numerical if unset, so the following got committed instead: http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~ltsp-upstream/ltsp/ltsp-trun

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
After some IRC discussion, here's what will be implemented: By default (X_COLOR_DEPTH="" or X_COLOR_DEPTH="smart"), thin clients get 16 bpp, and fat clients get the xorg default depth (usually 32). No special exceptions for thins with localapps. X_COLOR_DEPTH="auto" reverts to the old behavior,

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Vagrant Cascadian
On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 03:14:02PM +0300, Alkis Georgopoulos wrote: > Στις 26/03/2012 02:07 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: > > The situations where having =auto as the default would cause problems are: > > > > 1. Where clients don't support 16-bit colour and are not using local apps. > > Have you ever

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting Oliver Grawert : > oops, then i remembered it the wrong way round, sorry. > still, as mentioned in my other post, we should just rely on xorg > auto detection unless you really need to force the lower depth ... > (which i belive is what happens atm) Having been given some explanation of w

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Oliver Grawert
hi, On Mon, 26 Mar 2012 15:23:35 +0300 Alkis Georgopoulos wrote: > Oli the hardcoded X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 was removed in commit > http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~ltsp-upstream/ltsp/ltsp-trunk/revision/979 > with no bug reports mentioned. > oops, then i remembered it the wrong way round, sorry. still,

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Oliver Grawert
hi, On Mon, 26 Mar 2012 15:14:02 +0300 Alkis Georgopoulos wrote: > 2) X without a -depth parameter at all. > and if that wouldnt work this would be a reason to shout at the xorg devs and file a bug, xorg autodetects the depth from the EDID data the panel/screen provides. ciao oli pg

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
Στις 26/03/2012 01:50 μμ, ο/η Oliver Grawert έγραψε: > we had it as default for years, you should dig on launchpad iirc there > were bugs that made us change to 32 ... Oli the hardcoded X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 was removed in commit http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~ltsp-upstream/ltsp/ltsp-trunk/revision/979

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting Alkis Georgopoulos : > Στις 26/03/2012 02:07 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: >> The situations where having =auto as the default would cause problems are: >> >> 1. Where clients don't support 16-bit colour and are not using local apps. > > Have you ever actually seen clients that don't support 1

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
Στις 26/03/2012 02:07 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: > The situations where having =auto as the default would cause problems are: > > 1. Where clients don't support 16-bit colour and are not using local apps. Have you ever actually seen clients that don't support 16 bpp modes, or is that theoretical?

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting Alkis Georgopoulos : > Στις 26/03/2012 12:54 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: >> I don't think this setting -color depth- should be conditional, if >> there's going to be a default, it should be the same for all, >> otherwise it gets confusing. > > I strongly disagree; the default should be to tr

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
Στις 26/03/2012 12:54 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: > I don't think this setting -color depth- should be conditional, if > there's going to be a default, it should be the same for all, > otherwise it gets confusing. I strongly disagree; the default should be to try hard to work in all cases. That's t

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Oliver Grawert
hi, On Mon, 26 Mar 2012 12:44:04 +0300 Alkis Georgopoulos wrote: > What's the negative side of making that the default, so that the > average user wouldn't have to read all lts.conf options, detect that > one, create an lts.conf and set it there, before enjoying its speed > benefits? > we had it

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting Alkis Georgopoulos : > Στις 26/03/2012 12:04 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: >> If not, then I'll implement an X_COLOR_DEPTH=auto instead, which would >> give the above behavior (16 on thins, 32 on fats/localapps) only when >> requested from lts.conf. >> To be more positive in

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
Στις 26/03/2012 12:04 μμ, ο/η Ben Green έγραψε: >>> >> If not, then I'll implement an X_COLOR_DEPTH=auto instead, which would >>> >> give the above behavior (16 on thins, 32 on fats/localapps) only when >>> >> requested from lts.conf. > To be more positive in my response, the above would be an e

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Ben Green
Quoting Jan Middelkoop : >> If not, then I'll implement an X_COLOR_DEPTH=auto instead, which would >> give the above behavior (16 on thins, 32 on fats/localapps) only when >> requested from lts.conf. To be more positive in my response, the above would be an excellent addition. Cheers, == From B

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Jan Middelkoop
X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 here too. The extra resolution (which is hardly visible) doesn't outweigh the performance hit (which is very much visible). I think it's a good idea if it becomes default. :-) Met vriendelijke groet, Jan Middelkoop Recreatie en Zorg Groep B.V. -- Website: http://www.recreat

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Peter D Knight
Sounds OK to me, makes a lot of sense. It can easily be changed by those who need the better definition. I don't use video on my thin clients. Peter On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 9:05 AM, Alkis Georgopoulos wrote: > By default, X_COLOR_DEPTH is 32 for thin clients, which means that a > 320x240 youtub

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Helmut Lichtenberg
Alkis Georgopoulos schrieb am 26.03.2012 09:05: > So I propose a change in upstream LTSP to set X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by > default, if: > * LTSP_FATCLIENT is not set (fat clients would still default to 32), > * LOCAL_APPS_MENU is not set (so 32 for localapps browsers too), > * X_COLOR_DEPTH is no

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] Problem with Opensuse 12.1 64Bit

2012-03-26 Thread Jigish Gohil
On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 12:23 PM, Gerhard Damerau wrote: > Dear friends, > my fresh install of regular Opensuse 12.1 64Bit with  LTSP from > http://download.opensuse.org/repositories/server:/ltsp/openSUSE_12.1/ > did not succeed. The client starts with DHCP and dots,  I see the > typical menu and

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Asmo Koskinen
26.03.2012 10:19, Xavier Brochard kirjoitti: > I allways set X_COLOR_DEPTH=16, to save bandwith and CPU. Users never > complains, even when browsing high quality pictures (on low quality > screens...). > I aprove. Same here. Go ahead. Best Regards Asmo Koskinen.

Re: [Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Xavier Brochard
Le lundi 26 mars 2012 09:05:42 Alkis Georgopoulos, vous avez écrit : > By default, X_COLOR_DEPTH is 32 for thin clients, which means that a > 320x240 youtube video needs 73.728.000 bps bandwidth (30 fps, 32 bpp). > > Setting X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 for thin clients makes that video need exactly > half th

[Ltsp-discuss] Problem with Opensuse 12.1 64Bit

2012-03-26 Thread Gerhard Damerau
Dear friends, my fresh install of regular Opensuse 12.1 64Bit with LTSP from http://download.opensuse.org/repositories/server:/ltsp/openSUSE_12.1/ did not succeed. The client starts with DHCP and dots, I see the typical menu and can choose, but the booting of the client ends up 5 secondes late

[Ltsp-discuss] X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 by default for thin clients

2012-03-26 Thread Alkis Georgopoulos
By default, X_COLOR_DEPTH is 32 for thin clients, which means that a 320x240 youtube video needs 73.728.000 bps bandwidth (30 fps, 32 bpp). Setting X_COLOR_DEPTH=16 for thin clients makes that video need exactly half the bandwidth, i.e. 36.864.000 bps. Of course that doesn't only affect videos.