LSA-West, Vancouver, July 24 - 29

2005-05-24 Thread guy_and_liz Smith
Just a reminder about LSA West. There's still time to sign up. We have a great faculty (Ray Nurse, Steven Stubbs, Pat O'Brian, and Bob Barto). We will have courses on a range of topics for both ren and baroque players at all levels of expertise plus a lutebuilding course taught by Grant Tomlinso

Re: Ornamentation

2005-05-24 Thread Leonard Williams
About the relish: It may not have been clear in my posting that the note above the written note is plucked with the right hand as usual, and the written note is lightly plucked with the left hand finger as the latter is pulled from the strings. Leonard To get on or off this list see lis

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>Geometrical drawing of the whole front leads to template >for one half, by >definition reversible, based on the centre line/joint of the >front... Only in a perfect world If one locates the center line using plans from historical lutes, making a template from one side, then flipping i

Re: Ornamentation of Delacourt Pavin

2005-05-24 Thread Leonard Williams
Steven-- I haven't seen any responses posted to your query, so I'll give it a try. I'm using Stanley Beutens' "Meaning and Performance of Ornament Signs in English Lute Tablatures". If the dot before a note affects a fretted note, it is surely a "fall", which is called a "hammer o

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Tony Chalkley
Geometrical drawing of the whole front leads to template for one half, by definition reversible, based on the centre line/joint of the front... - Original Message - From: "Michael Thames" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: ; "Tony Chalkley" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Tuesday, May 24, 2005 9:31 PM Subje

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>I think that we all try to mirror the left and right (unless >there is a good >reason not to) - I'm talking of outline, not barring, bridge, >etc., but for >some reaon, the wood doesn't always share our aims. >Moreover, the templates >I have been taught to use are _always_ half the shape, to >avo

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>can reflect the difference in tension between treble and >bass. But what if >you apply the symmetry question to only the body and the >top without taking into >account the internal structure and bridge? Then is there a >reason for asymmetry? The bridges on all lutes are asymmetrical, that

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>++Yes, this is a nice design, but too large for me. I >assume you mean symmetry >with respect to the plane of reflection perpendicular to the >top. What would be the >harm in making the right side the mirror image of the left? >Is there some advantage >to an asymmetrical body? Marion, actually

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>...and bridges (especially those that predate saddles), (in >most cases) >internal bracing, string positioning in relation to the >soundbox >(especially if neck extensions and extra pegboxes/riders >are involved), >etc. All things considered, the profile of the >soundboard/soundbox can >strive to

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Tony Chalkley
Dear Marion et al., - Original Message - From: "Dr. Marion Ceruti" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Michael Thames" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: Sent: Tuesday, May 24, 2005 8:24 PM Subject: Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect > with respect to the plane of reflection perpendicular to the top. What woul

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 03:01 PM 5/24/2005, Dr. Marion Ceruti wrote: >...But what if >you apply the symmetry question to only the body and the top without >taking into >account the internal structure and bridge? Then is there a reason for >asymmetry? I think so, and the only reason for that single plane of symmetry

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
That is right! (Eugene always knows!!) Any asymmetry at the nut must be reflected in a similar asymmetry at the bridge, with or without a saddle. However, before the bridge is installed also inside the body, the bracing can reflect the difference in tension between trebble and bass. But what if you

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 02:24 PM 5/24/2005, Dr. Marion Ceruti wrote: >++Yes, you are right when applied to the lute body which can have >a plane of symmetry, this part can in theory be completely symmetrical >with respect to that plane. It is the nut and peg box that break the >symmetrical >pattern... ..and bridges

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
-Original Message- From: Michael Thames <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: May 24, 2005 11:09 AM To: "Dr. Marion Ceruti" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, guy_and_liz Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, LUTELIST , Manolo Laguillo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
> When it comes to >the physical >construction of musical instrument, high symmetry means >something relatively boring and the >lowest symmetry possible is necessary to construct an >instrument, such as a lute, that is designed >to emphasize the different roles of the left and right hands, >respect

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
"Perfect symmetry" is a term that is too vague to use in scientific descriptions. I don't know what it means unless it refers to the sphere, which allows all possible symmetry operations. It's not that highly symmetric objects don't exist in nature, nor does it have anything to do with the secon

Re: symm/asymm & perfect/imperfect

2005-05-24 Thread Michael Thames
>Crystals are only symmetrical to a point. It's a >convenient and reasonably >good approximation, but >perfect symmetry runs afoul of the second law of >>thermodynamics, leading to things like point defects >and dislocations OK, so I'm getting the idea that perfect symmetry does not exist in

Re: Stradivari lute?

2005-05-24 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 03:41 AM 5/24/2005, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >Copies of this book can be ordered at >http://www.hd01.com/cremonaviolins/english/ContactNav.asp for 12 €, plus >delivery fees. >I have called them and the book is available Thank you, Marcello. Eugene To get on or off this list see list info

Fwd: Re: The List! - effect on performance of holding position

2005-05-24 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Marion, Thank you for your response to my earlier email (below). Unfortunately I seem not to have made myself entirely clear - for which I'm sorry. The point I was trying to make was that if we are serious about Historically Informed Performance(HIP), then features such as technique, inclu

Re: Stradivari lute?

2005-05-24 Thread tipwbg4
Copies of this book can be ordered at http://www.hd01.com/cremonaviolins/english/ContactNav.asp for 12 €, plus delivery fees. I have called them and the book is available ciao, Marcello > Marvelous. Do you have the publisher of this text on hand? Do you know > if it's still available? To g