[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Taco Walstra
On Monday 07 August 2006 00:14, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- LGS-Europe [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You are destroying an essential element of the character of your wonderful instrument. Furthermore, you are denying yourself and your audience the chance to devellop a taste for what is an

[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Bernd Haegemann
Dear all, about thirty minutes of playing, large tears started to roll down her cheeks, and she stopped playing and said, I'm sorry, it's just that I miss the beautiful sound of the gut strings. Her teacher looked at my I have a comparable experience with my 6 year old son. One day

[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread LGS-Europe
Chris about gut strings in the past: our gut is _not_ their gut. (i.e. the exact same type of string that was made back in the day.) Therefore, whatever you decide I'd say that the gut strings of all the different gut string makers of today, with their variety of products with quite

[LUTE] Re: (was) Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread ariel abramovich
Hi all, we've been in the subject before, many times. As most of you, I've heard people playing lutes strung in all sort of materials, both in concerts and recordings, with good and bad instruments. I've also used both and had the chance to experiment a bit. There's no point in arguing about

[LUTE] WG: Re: (was) Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Thomas Schall
I cannot agree more. The only objection I would have to Ariel's point is that gut gives a different feeling for the player. When playing gut I feel a bit as if the fingers would be glued to the string I am trying to plug while gut players don't like the feeling of syntetic materials. Best

[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Mathias Rösel
I have a comparable experience with my 6 year old son. One day somebody wanted him to play some lute pieces by Waissel. But he handed him an edition in French tablature!! At once my son threw himself to the floor, weeping and swearing, because he plays it only from German tablature.

[LUTE] Re: (was) Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread LGS-Europe
Ariel I personally do not find strings material to be as relevant, but I do get your point, and I like myself more the sound of gut that of synthetic, but they're sometimes not as practical. It's true, life is all a matter of priorities. I have come to a point in my playing where I

[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Edward C. Yong
On 7/8/06 19:55, Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have a comparable experience with my 6 year old son. One day somebody wanted him to play some lute pieces by Waissel. But he handed him an edition in French tablature!! At once my son threw himself to the floor, weeping and

[LUTE] Re: Gut Strings for Lute

2006-08-07 Thread Rebecca Banks
August 7th, 2006 Dear Lutenists: With the brewing controversy of gut vs Nylgut strings, I would like to try gut strings on my Lute when it arrives. Where can one purchase mail order gut strings for a Bass Rennaissance Lute? I play my 12 string guitar with

[LUTE] Re: Gut Strings for Lute

2006-08-07 Thread Howard Posner
Rebecca Banks wrote: What do gut strings sound like? Rather like nylon. To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

[LUTE] Re: Gut Strings for Lute

2006-08-07 Thread Mathias Rösel
Howard Posner [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: Rebecca Banks wrote: What do gut strings sound like? Rather like nylon. to be precise, broken nylon strings will possibly be as mute as broken gut strings. -- Regards, Mathias http://de.geocities.com/mathiasroesel

[LUTE] Re: (was) Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Roman Turovsky
Amen. RT - Original Message - From: ariel abramovich [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lutenet lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Monday, August 07, 2006 4:40 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: (was) Strings for chittarone Hi all, we've been in the subject before, many times. As most of you, I've heard people

[LUTE] Re: Strings for chittarone

2006-08-07 Thread Roman Turovsky
sorry, the therefore is mistaken. I agree that gut strings were different, and surely they were because all the machines for creating super equal strings were not available ofcourse. The sound however will still be more or less the same. Even when strings perhaps less equal in the past,

[LUTE] Re: Gut Strings for Lute

2006-08-07 Thread Roman Turovsky
- Original Message - From: Mathias Rösel [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lute Net lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Monday, August 07, 2006 6:03 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Gut Strings for Lute Howard Posner [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: Rebecca Banks wrote: What do gut strings sound like? Rather

[LUTE] Re: Gut Strings

2006-08-07 Thread Rebecca Banks
August 7th, 2006 Dear Lutenists: I have done some research on the Internet and found AquilaU.S.A. makes gut and silk strings . . . it will be interesting to experiment and see how they sound. Of course after phosphorous winds it will be interesting to hear the different

[LUTE] Re: Castiglione and the lute

2006-08-07 Thread JCetra
Dear All: Some organs may have been clumsy, but there is a playable organ in Switzerland -- it's been recorded several times, including at least once by E. Power Biggs -- from before 1400 and it does not appear clumsy at all. Let's not sell early craftsmen short! Cheers, Jim -- To get on