[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-30 Thread David Tayler
Well, my example was really to show how tricky attribution is. But you can dig a bit further. In this case, you can go by the Grove, but the Grove is not really an authoritative source in that it is a secondary reference. Yes, we all read it, but it is a bit like Trader Joe's as well. The real

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Benjamin Narvey
Is Pastyme with Good Companye really not by Henry the VIII? Excuse this perhaps very silly question from a 17c-iste, but I always assumed it was actually by the great man himself - although there could easily be new information/finds/theories I am not aware of. I note however that the New

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Peter Martin
How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Richafort De mon triste deplaisir (Ness 121) follows the melody of Pastyme right the way through from beginning to end. Anyone know the words of the Richafort? 'De mon triste deplaisir' seems a long way away from 'Pastyme with good

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread Arthur Ness
- Original Message - From: Peter Martin [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lute list lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Saturday, March 29, 2008 5:46 AM Subject: [LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye | How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Richafort | De mon

[LUTE] Re: Fingering question/Pastyme with Good Companye

2008-03-29 Thread David Tayler
Well spotted Peter!!! dt At 02:46 AM 3/29/2008, you wrote: How amazing. I never noticed this before. But yes, Francesco's Richafort De mon triste deplaisir (Ness 121) follows the melody of Pastyme right the way through from beginning to end. Anyone know the words of the Richafort? 'De mon