[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread David Tayler
d >tuner things are an abomination. Well made normal pegs are just >fine. These geared things seem to be an attempt to compensate for poor pegs. > >Sterling > >- Original Message >From: Eugene C. Braig IV >To: lute-cs.dartmouth.edu >Sent: Mon, June 21, 2010 3

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Mast
> >> - Original Message >> From: Eugene C. Braig IV >> To: lute-cs.dartmouth.edu >> Sent: Mon, June 21, 2010 3:28:48 PM >> Subject: [LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute >> >> I remember when these came out, and have read all the com

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Martin
.dartmouth.edu >Sent: Mon, June 21, 2010 3:28:48 PM >Subject: [LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute > >I remember when these came out, and have read all the comments to follow on >this thread. I'm not entirely certain of the practical usefulness of this >

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Martin
I as well like my simple lute pegs as well. These new gears are very interesting, however! At 09:16 AM 6/22/2010, wolfgang wiehe wrote: >I like my simple lute pegs, I like the simple non-mechanized "1 to 1 >tuning-design" of old instruments. perhaps modern >guitar-tuning-mechanics are a re

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread wolfgang wiehe
I like my simple lute pegs, I like the simple non-mechanized "1 to 1 tuning-design" of old instruments. perhaps modern guitar-tuning-mechanics are a result of 19th century perfection... w. Original-Nachricht > Datum: Tue, 22 Jun 2010 09:17:23 -0400 > Von: Edward Mast > An:

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Mast
I'm sorry, Ed - I didn't make myself clear. I was answering a post in which (if I understood the writer correctly) it was said that the type of geared tuners found on guitars (NOT the geared pegs we've been discussing) could more inexpensively be used on lutes. These are what I think take more

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Martin
I do not understand what you mean, as they require no more space that traditional pegs. The "lute" gears are not pictured, as they are thinner than the violin "pegs" one sees. At 08:17 AM 6/22/2010, Edward Mast wrote: >It seems to me that another reason - beyond the weight of >guitar-type m

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Mast
It seems to me that another reason - beyond the weight of guitar-type machine tuners - for not using them on lutes would be the space they require. I think they would require that the tuners be more widely spaced and the peg box consequently much longer. Though more expensive, the geared pegs

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread Edward Martin
I do not know the exact weight, but the 8-course lute has 15 pegs, or should I say, gears. The lute's neck felt as though it was light, with absolutely no noticeable added weight. At 12:33 AM 6/22/2010, howard posner wrote: >Weight is a major issue, especially when you're putting 24 of >somet

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-22 Thread howard posner
Weight is a major issue, especially when you're putting 24 of something on one end of your instrument. So the increased weight of a standard machine tuning head is usually cited as the reason for not using them on lutes, which are much lighter than 19th-century guitars. I have never personally

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread sterling price
-cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Mon, June 21, 2010 3:28:48 PM Subject: [LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute I remember when these came out, and have read all the comments to follow on this thread.  I'm not entirely certain of the practical usefulness of this product unless one would want to replace

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
I remember when these came out, and have read all the comments to follow on this thread. I'm not entirely certain of the practical usefulness of this product unless one would want to replace pegs on an existing instrument with minimal modification to the instrument. I seem to recall geared tuners

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Edward Mast
These do sound like a positive, worthwhile innovation. I'd have to think about the risks involved with shipping my lute to a maker to have them installed, though. Ned On Jun 20, 2010, at 3:33 PM, David Tayler wrote: > At BFX 2010, I had the opportunity to play Dan Larson's Frey lute. > Well, fi

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Edward Mast
For sure (I think) one of the big advantages to gut is the lack of binding at the nut. Once you get to the wound synthetic lower strings, binding seems inevitable. At least on every instrument I've owned. Ned On Jun 21, 2010, at 12:38 AM, Edward Martin wrote: > Actually, this instrument is i

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Ron Andrico
which issue of Lute News featured the article. Ron Andrico www.mignarda.com > Date: Mon, 21 Jun 2010 08:08:49 -0500 > To: nedma...@aol.com; e...@gamutstrings.com > CC: vidan...@sbcglobal.net; lute@cs.dartmouth.edu > From: e...@gamutstrings.com > Subject: [LUTE] Re

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Edward Martin
Yes, they are permanently installed. ed At 07:52 AM 6/21/2010, Edward Mast wrote: >I seem to remember that the geared pegs for violins, cellos etc. are >glued in place to prevent slipping of the peg itself (of course the >gears don't slip). Is this necessary with the lute pegs? If not, >wh

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-21 Thread Edward Mast
I seem to remember that the geared pegs for violins, cellos etc. are glued in place to prevent slipping of the peg itself (of course the gears don't slip). Is this necessary with the lute pegs? If not, what keeps the pegs themselves (not the gears) from slipping in dry weather? Ned On Jun 20

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Edward Martin
Actually, this instrument is in all gut, including the treble, and the strings do not stick on the nut. I think he takes care in the polishing of it. At 11:09 PM 6/20/2010, Christopher Stetson wrote: >Hmmm... nice and oily, and the strings would cut their own grooves... > >C. >>>>

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Christopher Stetson
Hmmm... nice and oily, and the strings would cut their own grooves... C. >>> David Tayler 6/20/2010 9:55 PM >>> It did not stick on the nut--I think he used a real nut, like a Brazil nut. d At 06:23 PM 6/20/2010, you wrote: >It can be on many lutes, but not on this particu

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread David Tayler
It did not stick on the nut--I think he used a real nut, like a Brazil nut. d At 06:23 PM 6/20/2010, you wrote: >It can be on many lutes, but not on this particular nut. > >ed > >At 08:16 PM 6/20/2010, Miles Dempster wrote: > > >But isn't there still the problem of the strings sticking on the nut?

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Edward Martin
It can be on many lutes, but not on this particular nut. ed At 08:16 PM 6/20/2010, Miles Dempster wrote: >But isn't there still the problem of the strings sticking on the nut? > >Miles > >On 2010-06-20, at 9:07 PM, Edward Martin wrote: > > > I saw this lute in Dan Larson's shop yesterday. It is

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Miles Dempster
But isn't there still the problem of the strings sticking on the nut? Miles On 2010-06-20, at 9:07 PM, Edward Martin wrote: > I saw this lute in Dan Larson's shop yesterday. It is a very, very > nice Frei, and yes, the pegs, or kegs, or whatever you want to call > them, are very nice, very i

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Edward Martin
I saw this lute in Dan Larson's shop yesterday. It is a very, very nice Frei, and yes, the pegs, or kegs, or whatever you want to call them, are very nice, very interesting. They are, as DT says, smooth as butter, and they will never slip, as pegs do. They are plain, but very attractive.. I

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread David Tayler
The ones Dan had were small and light. He was saying 25-35 per peg, I think, in what used to be the dollar. The taper would have to be similar, to fit the holes, but since the "peg", or let's call it a "keg" , what the hay, doesn't rotate in the pegbox holes it does not have to be exact. dt At 0

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread David Tayler
That archlute has one of those Korg mics clipped on it, which you need for tuning at an exhibition, unless you have prehensile ears. It is the twin of mine, although it sounds a bit better than mine and is happy with Sarge. At 01:12 PM 6/20/2010, you wrote: >Thanks for the pictures, David! > >

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Edward Mast
I don't have geared pegs on my cello, but know a cellist - and a violinist - who does. They like them a lot. My questions would be: 1) How much would each peg for a lute cost? 2) Would they need to be fitted by a luthier, or could the player do it him/herself? 3) Assuming a peg with gears wei

[LUTE] Re: geared pegs and Dan Larson's lute

2010-06-20 Thread Mjos & Larson
Thanks for the pictures, David! Do I see a clip-on tuner on the extension in the "bfx11" photo? -- R On Jun 20, 2010, at 2:33 PM, David Tayler wrote: At BFX 2010, I had the opportunity to play Dan Larson's Frey lute. Well, first off, this was a really nice lute, and all gut strung with some