[LUTE] Re: phrasing and dynamics, was: Guitar and lute

2005-08-30 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
First, I agree; the should be to play it like you mean it. However, in dramatizing phrasing and dynamics in a way that is not necessarily implied in period sources, how HIP is it? Eugene At 07:17 AM 8/30/2005, lapis bleu wrote: keeping alive any piece of ancient music is something weird,

[LUTE] Re: phrasing and dynamics, was: Guitar and lute

2005-08-30 Thread lapis bleu
However, in dramatizing phrasing and dynamics in a way that is not necessarily implied in period sources, how HIP is it? one may be facing a sort of tradeoff - one may have to choose either to preserve (technical) praxis or (emotional) achievement. if one can't save them both, there are no

[LUTE] Re: phrasing and dynamics, was: Guitar and lute

2005-08-30 Thread Roman Turovsky
First, I agree; the should be to play it like you mean it. However, in dramatizing phrasing and dynamics in a way that is not necessarily implied in period sources, how HIP is it? Eugene As HIP as it gets, unless one subscribes to the Rooley theory. RT At 07:17 AM 8/30/2005, lapis bleu