Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-25 Thread Jon Murphy
Thank you David and Mat, I was familiar with divisions but hadn't realized that diminutions was synonymous. And even with divisions I had a problem separating them from ornamentation, such as shakes, etc. But as I think of it (and for those who think I state the obvious, bear with me, I'm

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-25 Thread David Rastall
Hi Jon, ...are the diminutions improvisations about the basic melody, or are they just a term for music notated with more than one note for the tactus In the sense we're talking about (that of Elizabethan divisions), I would say divisions are improvisions over the basic harmony, which

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-24 Thread Jon Murphy
Vance, I have to agree with you, in part. First the matter of thumb in or out. There I am out of my area, I don't know what you are speaking of in diminutions (I would have thought of that as a matter of volume or speed). But in my limited experience I have found a better sound with thumb in

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-24 Thread Mathias Rösel
Jon Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] schrieb: There I am out of my area, I don't know what you are speaking of in diminutions (I would have thought of that as a matter of volume or speed). Diminuitions, or divisions, is a kind of ornamenting a melodic line by splitting or dividing it into rows of

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-24 Thread David Rastall
On Tuesday, February 24, 2004, at 03:23 AM, Jon Murphy wrote: ...I don't know what you are speaking of in diminutions (I would have thought of that as a matter of volume or speed). Diminutions are groups of notes that represent a single beat. If you take a basic count of one-two-three-four

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-23 Thread Jon Murphy
Gentlemen, With all due respect, and with knowledge that I too often use personal examples, may I say that my lady took a picture on our new digital camera where I am definitely thumb in. I wasn't playing, although the lute was in my lap. I was smoking a cigarette before starting a song. As the

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-23 Thread Roman Turovsky
The only point here is that the paintings of the lutenists of the Renaissance, and other modern classical times, must be posed rather than live play - or else the painters had perfect memories for their subjects. Who is to say whether the musician was playing a run, or a chord, or just tuning

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-23 Thread Vance Wood
] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; Steffen Gliese [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, February 23, 2004 1:01 AM Subject: Re: The likeness of John Dowland Gentlemen, With all due respect, and with knowledge that I too often use personal examples, may I say that my lady took a picture on our new digital camera

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-22 Thread adS
to have found a likeness of John Dowland on the title page of a book of madrigals composed by Melchior Borhgrevinck and published in 1605 in Copenhagen. The argument put forward seemed pretty good, although I am no academic. I have not seen it referred to in the Lute Society Newsletter

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-22 Thread Roman Turovsky
What IS interesting, is the fact that the lute player is playing thumb out. It is NOT PARTICULARLY interesting. The iconographic ratio of IN/OUT is 50/50. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://turovsky.org http://polyhymnion.org

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-22 Thread Arto Wikla
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004, Roman Turovsky wrote: What IS interesting, is the fact that the lute player is playing thumb out. It is NOT PARTICULARLY interesting. The iconographic ratio of IN/OUT is 50/50. Really?! Could you elaborate that? You have a statistical analysis? Very interesting, indeed!

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-22 Thread Vance Wood
Subject: Re: The likeness of John Dowland What IS interesting, is the fact that the lute player is playing thumb out. It is NOT PARTICULARLY interesting. The iconographic ratio of IN/OUT is 50/50. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://turovsky.org http://polyhymnion.org

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-22 Thread Steffen Gliese
Arto Wikla wrote: What IS interesting, is the fact that the lute player is playing thumb out. It is NOT PARTICULARLY interesting. The iconographic ratio of IN/OUT is 50/50. Really?! Could you elaborate that? You have a statistical analysis? Very interesting, indeed! Could you share

Re: The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-21 Thread Arne Keller
Henriksen claimed to have found a likeness of John Dowland on the title page of a book of madrigals composed by Melchior Borhgrevinck and published in 1605 in Copenhagen. The argument put forward seemed pretty good, although I am no academic. I have not seen it referred to in the Lute Society

The likeness of John Dowland

2004-02-20 Thread Mashley256
Dear lute experts! I am curious to know what the view of the lute fraternity is to the article about Dowland that appeared in the Journal of the American Lute Society 1997 (which only arrived last year). This was the article where Olav Chris Henriksen claimed to have found a likeness of John