Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Chris Jones
> On 7 May 2021, at 8:33 pm, Ken Cunningham > wrote: > > There is one issue with that. > > qt5-qtcreator needs clang-10 on arm for it’s libraries (that is actually the > only reason why I initially fixed clang-10 to work on arm64 in the first > place). > > qt5-qtcreator cannot (could not

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Ken Cunningham
There is one issue with that. qt5-qtcreator needs clang-10 on arm for it’s libraries (that is actually the only reason why I initially fixed clang-10 to work on arm64 in the first place). qt5-qtcreator cannot (could not) use any newer clang when I checked six months ago. So — we still need cla

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Chris Jones
Hi, Another clean up suggestion is to remove all clangs apart from 11+ for macOS11(arm). I just noticed the buildbots building the clang-9.0 version for arm, but its worth noting that clang 9.0 and 10 are not reliable for arm, I have seen them generate bad code, fail with ICEs, so really there

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Mark Anderson
Yeah. I don’t know I ever use MPI in anything less than the latest clang or maybe one version back if they broke something. —Mark On Fri, May 7, 2021 at 3:11 PM Ken Cunningham < ken.cunningham.web...@gmail.com> wrote: > Yes, gcc7 works down to 10.4, both PPC and Intel and is the primary > compil

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Eric Borisch
Related: I mentioned on https://trac.macports.org/ticket/62807, I'm all in favor of aligning the mpich and openmpi compiler lists, too. Thanks, - Eric On Fri, May 7, 2021 at 2:11 PM Ken Cunningham < ken.cunningham.web...@gmail.com> wrote: > Yes, gcc7 works down to 10.4, both PPC and Intel and

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Ken Cunningham
Yes, gcc7 works down to 10.4, both PPC and Intel and is the primary compiler there. I can see no need for openMPI to support any older gcc. clang-3.3, clang-3.4, and clang-3.7 should not be used for anything other than bootstrapping to newer clangs now. Ken

Re: OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Chris Jones
Hi, I would suggest maybe its worth pruning the gcc list a bit as well ? I believe e.g. gcc7 at least works all the way down to 10.5, perhaps even older ? Do we still need gcc 5, 6? Chris > On 7 May 2021, at 1:35 pm, Christopher Nielsen > wrote: > > Folks, > > We’re considering retirement

OpenMPI Users - Is Anyone Using openmpi-clang33 or openmpi-clang34?

2021-05-07 Thread Christopher Nielsen
Folks, We’re considering retirement of ports openmpi-clang33 and openmpi-clang34, to reduce the number of openmpi-* ports we support. At the moment, the list is quite large, and it’s becoming a challenge to thoroughly test and maintain all of these: openmpi-clang @4.1.1