Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-04 Thread tz
I was hoping to spark a discussion, and I think it worked out better than I was expecting for a rant. My thoughts on extras: (maybe instead of karma it should be called extras credit?). * I don't do games, so I would consider user/games as cluttered as someone else might consider user/cli. I

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-04 Thread tz
To extend or clarify another issue: There are things which should be and are in other sections like python and associated libs. Lots of things like this and cli stuff are building-blocks, i.e. I might want to use a maintained and tested utility for several things and which others can use instead

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Marius Vollmer
ext Jeremiah Foster jerem...@jeremiahfoster.com writes: Then Application Manager has to change. It does not scale to have categories when there are thousands of apps. Yes, this is overdue. We also need a way to handle application specific add-ons, like language packs.

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 10:47, Marius Vollmer marius.voll...@nokia.com wrote: ext Jeremiah Foster jerem...@jeremiahfoster.com writes: Then Application Manager has to change. It does not scale to have categories when there are thousands of apps. Yes, this is overdue.  We also need a way to

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Marius Vollmer
ext Pauli Virtanen p...@iki.fi writes: A separate tree of categories could be useful. Though maybe it would be better to name it 'expert/*', and warn in the UI that these are expert tools that really may require expertise to use properly or safely. What would it take to have the application

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Dieter Plaetinck
On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 10:51:25 + Andrew Flegg and...@bleb.org wrote: On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 10:47, Marius Vollmer marius.voll...@nokia.com wrote: ext Jeremiah Foster jerem...@jeremiahfoster.com writes: Then Application Manager has to change. It does not scale to have categories when

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Eero Tamminen
Hi, ext Andrew Flegg wrote: On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 10:47, Marius Vollmer marius.voll...@nokia.com wrote: ext Jeremiah Foster jerem...@jeremiahfoster.com writes: Then Application Manager has to change. It does not scale to have categories when there are thousands of apps. Yes, this is

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Pauli Virtanen
Mon, 02 Nov 2009 09:20:41 +0200, Matan Ziv-Av wrote: On Sun, 1 Nov 2009, Andrew Flegg wrote: Then there's no benefit to having them visible in HAM. The tool which started this discussion, socat, could easily be installed by someone doing `apt-get install socat' as root. Do you know that

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread David Greaves
On Mon, 2009-11-02 at 06:47 +0100, Benoît HERVIER wrote: Are you all kidding ? seriously ? The bug Way too geeky to present to most users should, IMHO be an 'extras user/*' criteria. I am serious. For goodness sake didn't you spot that the device ships with a Facebook applet? If the device

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Jeremiah Foster
On Nov 2, 2009, at 21:17, David Greaves wrote: If the device is to succeed then even people who believe horoscopes must be comfortable using it! You must be a taurus . . . Accidentally presenting them with a network sniffer application is, IMHO, a user experience bug. Does we need to

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-02 Thread Graham Cobb
On Monday 02 November 2009 11:28:04 Eero Tamminen wrote: I don't understand why CLI tools need any specific section. That just makes porting (re-compiling) them from Debian more hassle. The value of being able to install them from AM GUI in addition to using apt-get install on command line

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Martin Grimme
Hi, it really looks wrong IMHO if stuff like socat, rootsh, or openssh turn up in the extras repository ready for end-users to be installed. extras should only contain applications that are safe for everyone to play around with. Stuff like this is meant for advanced users and developers. I think

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 09:30, Martin Grimme martin.gri...@gmail.com wrote: it really looks wrong IMHO if stuff like socat, rootsh, or openssh turn up in the extras repository ready for end-users to be installed. extras should only contain applications that are safe for everyone to play around

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Graham Cobb
On Sunday 01 November 2009 10:22:00 Andrew Flegg wrote: On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 09:30, Martin Grimme martin.gri...@gmail.com wrote: it really looks wrong IMHO if stuff like socat, rootsh, or openssh turn up in the extras repository ready for end-users to be installed. extras should only

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 11:35, Graham Cobb g+...@cobb.uk.net wrote: On Sunday 01 November 2009 10:22:00 Andrew Flegg wrote: However, if it is clear to users what to expect when they install those apps; and they don't recklessly reduce the capability of the system, I don't think they're that

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Luca Olivetti
En/na Martin Grimme ha escrit: I think it would be best to have another official repository extras-advanced for these things, that comes preconfigured but deactivated on the device, with a big warning that apps in there are meant for advanced users who know what these tools are. I thought

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread David Greaves
On Sat, 2009-10-31 at 19:10 -0700, tz wrote: I'm a power user and not the only one. Agreed. And what I used my current tablets for were testing networks and doing other low level stuff, mainly from xterm, but sometimes from python front-ends to linux. So I ported a number of utilities under

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Aniello Del Sorbo
2009/11/1 Andrew Flegg and...@bleb.org: On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 11:35, Graham Cobb g+...@cobb.uk.net wrote: On Sunday 01 November 2009 10:22:00 Andrew Flegg wrote: However, if it is clear to users what to expect when they install those apps; and they don't recklessly reduce the capability of

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Andrea Borgia
Martin Grimme ha scritto: it really looks wrong IMHO if stuff like socat, rootsh, or openssh turn up in the extras repository ready for end-users to be installed. extras should only contain applications that are safe for everyone to play around with. The application manager already pops up

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Pauli Virtanen
su, 2009-11-01 kello 09:46 +, David Greaves kirjoitti: [clip] Alongside 'user/*' I wonder if we should have a 'geek/*' section ? Or make 'user/development' and some other categories only visible if enabled in preferences. Personally I think we're back at the Categories argument that was

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Andrew Flegg
On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 19:21, Pauli Virtanen p...@iki.fi wrote: What would it take to have the application manager to have a setting Show expert tools that would show/hide these? I'm slightly familiar with the HAM code, it should be fairly trivial. Getting it into users' hands is slightly

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Jeremiah Foster
On Nov 1, 2009, at 12:35, Graham Cobb wrote: On Sunday 01 November 2009 10:22:00 Andrew Flegg wrote: On Sun, Nov 1, 2009 at 09:30, Martin Grimme martin.gri...@gmail.com wrote: it really looks wrong IMHO if stuff like socat, rootsh, or openssh turn up in the extras repository ready for

Fwd: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Jeremiah Foster
Begin forwarded message: From: Jeremiah Foster jerem...@jeremiahfoster.com Date: November 2, 2009 12:35:45 AM GMT+01:00 To: Andrew Flegg and...@bleb.org Subject: Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle? On Nov 1, 2009, at 12:55, Andrew Flegg

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Benoît HERVIER
Are you all kidding ? seriously ? The bug Way too geeky to present to most users should, IMHO be an 'extras user/*' criteria. Does we need to come back to the old days where each user have his own repository ? To be honest i ll be far away easier to do than the actual one. 2009/11/2 Jeremiah

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Matan Ziv-Av
On Sun, 1 Nov 2009, Andrew Flegg wrote: Then there's no benefit to having them visible in HAM. The tool which started this discussion, socat, could easily be installed by someone doing `apt-get install socat' as root. Do you know that almost any current Linux distribution has a GUI package

Re: Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-11-01 Thread Andrew Flegg
Benoît, you wrote: Are you all kidding ? seriously ? The bug Way too geeky to present to most users should, IMHO be an 'extras user/*' criteria. Does we need to come back to the old days where each user have his own repository ? To be honest i ll be far away easier to do than the actual

Why should it be so hard and should I even bother with Extras for fremantle?

2009-10-31 Thread tz
I'm a power user and not the only one. And what I used my current tablets for were testing networks and doing other low level stuff, mainly from xterm, but sometimes from python front-ends to linux. So I ported a number of utilities under Linux to maemo/diablo and started to do it for fremantle.