[Marxism] Rape Instinct?

2009-08-05 Thread Jscotlive
Tom Cod: No dude, that's not a defense that is very helpful as it assumes that this happened and then makes excuses for it. Moreover, it is a slap in the face to the millions of soviet soldiers and partisans who didn't do things like that. I'm not sure what your experiences in war or milita

Re: [Marxism] "Rape instinct"??

2009-08-05 Thread Tom Cod
No dude, that's not a defense that is very helpful as it assumes that this happened and then makes excuses for it. Moreover, it is a slap in the face to the millions of soviet soldiers and partisans who didn't do things like that. I'm not sure what your experiences in war or military life are

Re: [Marxism] "Rape instinct"??

2009-08-05 Thread Jeff
At 17:18 05/08/09 EDT, you wrote: > >Well, let's see. If, as I do, you consider rape a form of violence yes... >, and the > purpose of war to inflict more violence on your enemy than they inflict on >you That sounds like a prescription for war crimes of every sort! War is normally defended as ha

Re: [Marxism] "Rape instinct"??

2009-08-05 Thread Jay Clinton
as used here more generically, but imprecisely onĀ  a list where science is commonly discussed. --- On Wed, 5/8/09, jscotl...@aol.com wrote: From: jscotl...@aol.com Subject: [Marxism] "Rape instinct"?? To: "jc" Date: Wednesday, 5 August, 2009, 9:18 PM Jeff, quoting me: The n

[Marxism] "Rape instinct"??

2009-08-05 Thread Jscotlive
Jeff, quoting me: The notion that the Soviet troops would be shorn of the same human base >instincts when involved in such a brutal war as any other troops are >idealistic in the extreme. Then writes: I won't even start on this one Reply: Well, let's see. If, as I do, you consider r

[Marxism] "Rape instinct"??

2009-08-05 Thread Jeff
At 16:40 05/08/09 EDT, jscotl...@aol.com wrote: > >The notion that the Soviet troops would be shorn of the same human base >instincts when involved in such a brutal war as any other troops is >idealistic in the extreme. I won't even start on this one - Jeff _