Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-08 Thread Aaron Mason
On Fri, Jan 8, 2010 at 7:09 PM, Tom Murphy wrote: > Aaron - > > Not sure if this has been mentioned yet, but maybe you need to > match the inbound traffic so that the related traffic going back > out will fall into the proper queue? > > e.g. > > pass in on $wired_if to $chechemaru queued wired_

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-08 Thread Tom Murphy
Aaron - Not sure if this has been mentioned yet, but maybe you need to match the inbound traffic so that the related traffic going back out will fall into the proper queue? e.g. pass in on $wired_if to $chechemaru queued wired_lo I've found with BitTorrent, Soulseek and other P2P-like t

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-06 Thread Aaron Mason
On Thu, Jan 7, 2010 at 10:13 AM, Robert wrote: > On Thu, 7 Jan 2010 09:47:45 +1100 > Aaron Mason wrote: > >> altq on $wired_if cbq bandwidth 54Mb queue { wired_hi, wired_norm, > > Without taking anything else into account: > wireless G network ... That 54Mb limit is too high. > You should first r

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-06 Thread Robert
On Thu, 7 Jan 2010 09:47:45 +1100 Aaron Mason wrote: > altq on $wired_if cbq bandwidth 54Mb queue { wired_hi, wired_norm, Without taking anything else into account: wireless G network ... That 54Mb limit is too high. You should first reduce it by the overhead and then take some more off for good

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-06 Thread Aaron Mason
On Thu, Jan 7, 2010 at 5:09 AM, Calomel Org wrote: > Aaron, > > When you say, "seem to spill over into the normal queue" do you mean > the bittor queue is borrowing bandwidth from the total amount of > bandwidth available? No, what I mean is when the low priority queue fills up, it seems to find

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-06 Thread Calomel Org
Aaron, When you say, "seem to spill over into the normal queue" do you mean the bittor queue is borrowing bandwidth from the total amount of bandwidth available? You may need to set a limit on the bittor queue if you want to limit its bandwidth. The OpenBSD Faq says, CBQ queues are arranged in an

Re: PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-05 Thread Randal L. Schwartz
> "Aaron" == Aaron Mason writes: Aaron> hi_bw = "33Mb" Aaron> norm_bw = "20Mb" Aaron> lo_bw = "178415b" Aaron> A typical output from pftop shows the contents of Aaron> http://paste2.org/p/596043 - notice the upstream going crazy. Aaron> Unfortunately pfTop hasn't been updated to take adv

PF cluestick please - low priority queue spills over into normal queue

2010-01-05 Thread Aaron Mason
Hi all, I've got the following pf.conf file for limiting bittorrent connections and providing higher priority to a game server. While the latter works wonderfully, the bittorrent connections seem to spill over into the normal queue and it's driving me crazy. My /etc/pf.conf file is as follows: s