Re: [mb-style] RFC STYLE-97: Move "medley" to an attribute of "performance of"

hello, I also share the concerns about definition of medley stated here and agree that it would be better under "a performance of" relation, but I also agree with caller#6, that you gave a really vague meaning to medley here. So, I came up with the idea of using the word "juxtapose" as a wider grou

Re: [mb-style] Track artist = track artist?

here is another example from me: I seen releases where in tracks it says "Artist X & Choir" and as you can guess, who that choir is completely unknown. No information anywhere on the release... So in these cases, I too would like to see that artist as "Artist X & Choir" in a player, but also I woul

Re: [mb-style] RFC STYLE-97: Move "medley" to an attribute of "performance of"

> > I'd be inclined to keep it simple and enter potpourris and quodlibets as > medleys. My gut feeling is that creating separate subcategories for them > would generate lots of unwinnable arguments ("It's a potpourri!" "No, it's > a > medley!") without adding much value to the database. > These ty

Re: [mb-style] RFC-348: Recording and track artist

hi, just wanted to say that I also think that the Artist field for the Recording objects are not needed and existence of such a field makes everything more complicated. In other words, if there is no example where a Recording and related Tracks has different artists, why are we repeating it? Of cou

Re: [mb-style] pre-RFC2-320: Revised Sort Name Style - identifying the problems that need fixing

sorry for jumping in just wanted to ask a question that I was trying to answer to myself while ago. The problem is we (Turkish people) do not sort names as "family name, name" in general (ie: everyone will look to letter 'S' to find Sezen Aksu). We even do not care if "The Doors" is sorted as "Door

Re: [mb-style] Sort Names: sorting vs. grouping ?

2012/5/8 Ross Tyler > > I think what most people expect from the sort name field is that artists > > be ordered in a familiar alphabetical manner. The purpose of that is > > simply to find an artist in a list when you know nothing beyond the name. > Yes. > I consider myself one of these. > I (and,

[mb-style] RFC: Capitalization Standard Turkish

Hello all, I've completed the capitalization standard guideline for the Turkish language (RFC-9 ). I used the "writing guidelines" from the Turkish Language Societyweb page as the main source, because they

Re: [mb-style] RFC: Capitalization Standard Turkish

Hello Brian, Thanks for reminding me about that bug. I certainly have no objections about removing that note, in case the bug is solved. thanks. --ym 2010/5/31 Brian Schweitzer > Thanks again for finishing up this proposal. :) > > +1 from me. > > This proposal will go to RFV on 2010-06-06. >