Re: [mb-style] CSG: Releases and Recordings with multiple alternative credits

2013-04-20 Thread monxton
On 20/04/2013 01:51, pabouk wrote: I did not read all the discussion yet but I think that the recordings should be credited to the real artists because there are many cases where the same recording is released with real credits and also with Alfred Scholz credits. IMHO such recording should

[mb-style] CSG: Releases and Recordings with multiple alternative credits

2013-04-19 Thread monxton
This is another what's printed on the cover vs. what we know dilemma, and I'd appreciate a discussion among classical editors who care. The problem is how to handle the recordings of Alfred Scholz, a prolific creator of budget classical recordings the 1970s. I won't go into all the details

Re: [mb-style] CSG: Releases and Recordings with multiple alternative credits

2013-04-19 Thread monxton
On 19/04/2013 23:41, Frederic Da Vitoria wrote: (...) Moving back here for the discussion. My last suggestion was creating one dummy artist for this. Dummy because we don't know who the real artist(s) for those performances is/are. This dummy artist could have aliases to allow using him in an

Re: [mb-style] CSG: Releases and Recordings with multiple alternative credits

2013-04-19 Thread pabouk
I did not read all the discussion yet but I think that the recordings should be credited to the real artists because there are many cases where the same recording is releases with real credits and also with Alfred Scholz cerdits. IMHO such recording should not exist in multiple copies and they