Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-21 Thread jlewis
The off-topic nanog thread that won't die (where are the topic police?...never around when you need one)...and then just when you think it has died, some member's virus infected Microsoft Windows PC (hey is that redundant?) replies to you with the thread's subject and no body other than a virus

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-20 Thread Neil J. McRae
I think it was the new MG F, where if you had the top down on the car and there was moisture on the boot [trunk] when you opened the boot [trunk] people in the car would get showered! They fixed it by adding a tighter spring so that the boot [trunk] opened slowly and the water dripped down the

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-20 Thread Wojtek Zlobicki
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? Without a question: PS/2 style keyboard and mouse connectors. Impossible to tell from each other, or the right way up without eyeballs directly on them. A real PITA when trying to reach behind a desk or rack. The console port

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Mark Borchers
1. Any device whose physical characteristics make it a likely candidate to be shelf-mounted, yet which has side ventilation ports which will be blocked by the sides of a rack shelf. 2. The BAT csu/dsu, a cheap T1 csu/dsu which used red LED's to indicate that all was well (or was it green to

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Christopher L. Morrow
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Ben Browning wrote: Cisco V-notched power cables - Design feature geared around getting suckers to buy a power cable for 45USD. No! those are great!! you get to yell at the poor sap that uses your Cisco power cable on their monitor! :) And when they do, and you can't

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Leo Bicknell
In a message written on Thu, Sep 18, 2003 at 03:53:44PM -0700, Ben Browning wrote: Cisco V-notched power cables - Design feature geared around getting suckers to buy a power cable for 45USD. Uh, you might want to be careful with these connections. You'll note the IEC-320 C13/C14 connectors

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Chris Horry
RJ45 connectors: Nasty fiddly things that never seem to work the first time you wire them up. (snip, curse, try again...) Chris -- Chris Horry Don't submit to stupid rules, [EMAIL PROTECTED] Be yourself and not a fool. PGP: DSA/2B4C654E Don't accept average habits, Amateur

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Scott Granados
Just to clerify, since I've gotten a ton of these. I'm totally blind have been for 28 years. Braille on walk up machines, makes good sense. As does it on lifts and microwave oven buttons etc. It does not make good sense on airplane lights and it makes less sense on drive up atms. Especialy

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Fri, 19 Sep 2003 12:08:33 PDT, Scott Granados said: noise anyway. So that someone looking over your shoulder will still be there unless you've memorized the prompts on your local atm, a possibility granted. Works for my dad - though he did have to call the bank once, turned out they had

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Mike Donahue
At 04:24 PM 9/18/2003, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The US Congress. can you say ADA - sure you can - Fred Rodgers Who thought it was a good idea to put braille on the drive up atms? While I don't know if the person in question was blind or not, I *have* seen someone use a drive-up ATM from

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Damian Gerow
Thus spake Mike Donahue ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [19/09/03 15:28]: Hi.. I might have missed the post, but braille on drive through has zero to do with a design mistake - it's practicality. The ATM manufacturer doesn't put out a drive-through and walk-up model - it puts out one, and then it's up

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Scott Granados
Actually, not what I've heard. I have a contact at a large east coast bank who told me they were charged extra for Braille per ATM. I had assumed for years it was a case of build them all one way only to save cost. But in fact this is not the case. At least for the type they use. On Fri, 19

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Shawn Jackson
: Friday, September 19, 2003 11:34 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? Thus spake Mike Donahue ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [19/09/03 15:28]: Hi.. I might have missed the post, but braille on drive through has zero to do with a design mistake - it's practicality. The ATM manufacturer

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Alex Rubenstein
2. The BAT csu/dsu, a cheap T1 csu/dsu which used red LED's to indicate that all was well (or was it green to indicate an alarm?) As admitted by them, whatever cheap LED's they could by at Fry's on deep discount. No, I am not kidding. -- Alex Rubenstein, AR97, K2AHR, [EMAIL PROTECTED],

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread John Neiberger
Scott Granados [EMAIL PROTECTED] 9/19/03 1:36:39 PM Actually, not what I've heard. I have a contact at a large east coast bank who told me they were charged extra for Braille per ATM. I had assumed for years it was a case of build them all one way only to save cost. But in fact this is not

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread steve uurtamo
It's usually a legal risk deferrer decision to buy the ATM casing with Braille. Someone pointed out that Drive-Ups and Walk-Ups are the same, which it true for the internals but not Drive-Ups casing and moldings, which are adjusted for the average eye level of a person in a car, plus

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Ron Snyder
overdesigned rather than poorly designed. even if nobody can use it, it's just an extraneous feature. an atm built into the concrete that you'd have to stop short of and get out of your car to use. now that would be poorly designed. /lurk Do you mean overdesigned in the sense that

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Matt
PROTECTED] Subject: RE: Worst design decisions? The 12016 does have handles on the sides, but the documentation states not to use them for lifting purposes. Yeah, I laughed too, just before realizing that bear-hugging a 16 into position takes a bit of motivation. It is definitely one big hunk

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-19 Thread Matt
Frank wrote: On Thu, 2003-09-18 at 00:43, Matt wrote: Hello all, Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design perspective to rant about. I'll start with a

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Frank
On Thu, 2003-09-18 at 00:43, Matt wrote: Hello all, Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design perspective to rant about. I'll start with a couple. the

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Petri Helenius
Frank wrote: the orginal GSR blanks came without handles. They were also put in tight as ***. For days after, your fingers would have the imprints of the little screws on them. I once use my socks to protect my fingers when I was pulling them out. Some Cisco gear also arrived with the flash

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread David Lesher
Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: Hello all, Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design perspective to rant about. I'll

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Ryan Dobrynski
I have beef with every chasis designer that has ever left a sharp edge hidden deep inside thier case of doom just waiting to gash some poor IT guy in a most unpleasent manor.. also ASUS who insists on putting thier onboard sound interface at the BOTTOM of the MB when they know that the little

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Vinny Abello
At 08:57 AM 9/18/2003, David Lesher wrote: Speaking on Deep Background, the Press Secretary whispered: Hello all, Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Vinny Abello
How about MB chipset fans which always seem to fail! I avoid any mobo with a chipset fan if possible. This is still commonplace and I still see them fail all the time. At 09:09 AM 9/18/2003, Ryan Dobrynski wrote: I have beef with every chasis designer that has ever left a sharp edge hidden

Re: Worst design decisions? (Cisco 4x00 rails)

2003-09-18 Thread neal rauhauser
Cisco 4x00 frame rails are the king - bend 'em and you'll be using a chisel to open the metal chassis so you can remove the NPs. I've still got a 4000 around here somewhere that was shuffled to lab duty after I did surgery on it with a large cold chisel mallet. Matt wrote: Hello all,

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Daryl G. Jurbala
* How about the plastic stand-offs that hold the AIM-VPN cards in the 2600 and 1700 series. Yeah...the ones that DON'T come with your SmartNet replacement chassis and that you have the pull the entire board to release. * And how about this: Cisco: PICK A BUSINESS END ON YOUR SMALL OFFICE

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread David Lesher
Sorry, I missed the hands-down winner in my initial thinking, since it's not in my arena [hardware].. The envelope please.. Micro$loth Lookout {applause} Starting with Let's invent top-posting and moving to its virus-spreading abilities; Lookout has never met a standard, either

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Todd Vierling
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, David Lesher wrote: : Sorry, I missed the hands-down winner in my initial thinking, : since it's not in my arena [hardware].. Oh, the hardware one's easy, though. The modern PC, which does not by default come with a remote management (typically RS-232) system-level

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Brian Bruns
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:01 AM Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? Sorry, I missed the hands-down winner in my initial thinking, since it's not in my arena [hardware].. The envelope please.. Micro$loth Lookout {applause} Starting with Let's invent top

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Austad, Jay
Sun Ultra Enterprise 3500. Three power supplies for redundancy, only *one* power cord. You'd think that with something that originally cost 6 figures, that this would have been thought out a bit more. Oh, and 1U patch panels with only 12 ports in them annoy me. -Original Message-

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread David Barak
--- Matt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've got a couple others in my head from 3Com and a couple of others, but I thought I'd get the ball rolling. So, what do you think? Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit to the HUGE variety of console pinouts used by the

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread up
Without a question: PS/2 style keyboard and mouse connectors. Impossible to tell from each other, or the right way up without eyeballs directly on them. A real PITA when trying to reach behind a desk or rack. The console port is a close second, though... On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, David Barak

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Todd Vierling
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : Without a question: PS/2 style keyboard and mouse connectors. Impossible : to tell from each other, And this part is somewhat funny, too, because the PS/2 connector layout is capable of having both devices share the same bus (there's two

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Bob German
the thick, unwieldy cables to lift the unscrewed end ever-so-slightly out of its socket. -bob -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:57 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Worst design decisions

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Gerald
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Daryl G. Jurbala wrote: * PCs with built in Ethernet that is so close to a lip on the case, with the release pointed down, that you need to use a screwdriver/knife/whatever to release the cable. ...and combine that with the RJ45 connecters that have a rubber hood over

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Justin Shore
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, David Barak wrote: --- Matt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I've got a couple others in my head from 3Com and a couple of others, but I thought I'd get the ball rolling. So, what do you think? Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread John Palmer
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:16 Subject: RE: Worst design decisions? On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Daryl G. Jurbala wrote: * PCs with built in Ethernet that is so close to a lip on the case, with the release pointed down, that you need to use a screwdriver/knife/whatever

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Justin Shore
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Todd Vierling wrote: On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : Without a question: PS/2 style keyboard and mouse connectors. Impossible : to tell from each other, And this part is somewhat funny, too, because the PS/2 connector layout is capable of having

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Colin Brown
I can't stand it when I sit down and find the keyboard in front of me has moved the backslash key. It drives me crazy and prompts me to find a real keyboard right away to work with. CB

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Todd Vierling
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, John Palmer wrote: : ...and combine that with the RJ45 connecters that have a rubber hood over : the release. Gr! : Thats to prevent it from being disconnected accidentally : (or for any other reason :-) Actually, the original intent of those hoods was to snagproof

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread John Kristoff
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 09:53:38 -0400 Daryl G. Jurbala [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: * And how about this: Cisco: PICK A BUSINESS END ON YOUR SMALL OFFICE ROUTING EQUIPMENT. Most of my less clued customer like to help out and rack the equipment ahead of time. And it always gets done pretty side

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Peter E. Fry
David Barak wrote: Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit to the HUGE variety of console pinouts used by the various hardware vendors? Just look at vendor C as an example [...] Is that the best example you can come up with? Ever use any Bay equipment...?

Re: Worst design decisions? (Cisco 4x00 rails)

2003-09-18 Thread Mark Rogaski
My vote goes to the EMI gasket Cisco's BPX 8600 cards. The gasket was tacky enough to maintain a nice seal between cards ... enough to remove one or two adjacent cards when you pulled the card out. Special runner up nominee is whatever do-gooder decided it was a good idea to have a cell phone

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread E.B. Dreger
PEF Date: Thu, 18 Sep 2003 11:02:08 -0500 PEF From: Peter E. Fry PEF Is that the best example you can come up with? Ever use any PEF Bay equipment...? You have reminded me of Bay's config GUI. I shall have nightmares tonight. Eddy -- Brotsman Dreger, Inc. - EverQuick Internet Division

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Petri Helenius
David Barak wrote: Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit to the HUGE variety of console pinouts used by the various hardware vendors? Just look at vendor C as an example [...] Makes me remember when representatives from mentioned vendor made funny looks when

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Dominic J. Eidson
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, E.B. Dreger wrote: PEF From: Peter E. Fry PEF Is that the best example you can come up with? Ever use any PEF Bay equipment...? You have reminded me of Bay's config GUI. I shall have nightmares tonight. How about BCC? bcc#config ... wait ... -- Dominic J.

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Brian Bruns
- Original Message - From: E.B. Dreger [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 1:04 PM Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? You have reminded me of Bay's config GUI. I shall have nightmares tonight. Ah, the days when I used

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Ryan Tucker
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 17:04:47 + (GMT), E.B. Dreger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You have reminded me of Bay's config GUI. I shall have nightmares tonight. Back in the winter of '00, I had the pleasure of working on a friend's old Bay. He was using it for a home-based ISP, and, well, I believe

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Aaron Dewell
Even better: the old bay switches had a backdoor password, that you could always use no matter what. Great security there. G. I had to deal with a campus full of them, and since they had of course forgotten all the passwords, so it was a good thing in that case, I could actually

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Nathan J. Mehl
In the immortal words of Justin Shore ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): Applause I can think of 6 different console cable pinouts and connectors that Enterasys (Cabletron) has used over the years. No wait, make that 7. How could I forget the inherited Fore ATM architecture and subsequent blades.

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread John Neiberger
The hands-down winner, so far, is the Cisco CMS-formerly-known-as-Arrowpoint, which has an RJ45 console cable which WILL NOT WORK, full stop, with the RJ45 connectors on Cisco's own console servers. *wild applause* Ah, yes. I've run into that bad boy. It really stinks to come in to work in the

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread up
, September 18, 2003 10:16 Subject: RE: Worst design decisions? On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Daryl G. Jurbala wrote: * PCs with built in Ethernet that is so close to a lip on the case, with the release pointed down, that you need to use a screwdriver/knife/whatever to release the cable

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Gerald
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Actually, as awkward as those rubber hoods are, what I like about them is that when you're pulling a disconnected patch cable through a rat's nest of wires, they prevent the plastic tab from being bent backward. Since you are the second person to

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Luke Starrett
, September 18, 2003 10:16 Subject: RE: Worst design decisions? On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Daryl G. Jurbala wrote: * PCs with built in Ethernet that is so close to a lip on the case, with the release pointed down, that you need to use a screwdriver/knife/whatever to release

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Nathan Eric Norman
On Thu, Sep 18, 2003 at 02:39:51PM -0400, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Actually, as awkward as those rubber hoods are, what I like about them is that when you're pulling a disconnected patch cable through a rat's nest of wires, they prevent the plastic tab from being bent backward. Not a

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread bdragon
Hello all, Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design perspective to rant about. I'll start with a couple. snip try cisco-nsp. Single vendor stuff is

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Mr. James W. Laferriere
Hello All , On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Gerald wrote: On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Actually, as awkward as those rubber hoods are, what I like about them is that when you're pulling a disconnected patch cable through a rat's nest of wires, they prevent the plastic tab

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Ejay Hire
] Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? David Barak wrote: Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit to the HUGE variety of console pinouts used by the various hardware vendors? Just look at vendor C as an example [...] Is that the best example you can come up

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Charles Sprickman
] To: Daryl G. Jurbala [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: nanog list [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:16 Subject: RE: Worst design decisions? On Thu, 18 Sep 2003, Daryl G. Jurbala wrote: * PCs with built in Ethernet that is so close to a lip

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Charles Sprickman
. Fry [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 11:02 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Worst design decisions? David Barak wrote: Personally my issues are console-cable related: is there a benefit to the HUGE variety of console pinouts used by the various hardware

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Miquel van Smoorenburg
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Todd Vierling [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: : Without a question: PS/2 style keyboard and mouse connectors. Impossible : to tell from each other, And this part is somewhat funny, too, because the PS/2 connector layout is

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Ben Browning
Was doing some upgrades on a UBR7246 (to a VXR), and I got to thinking about short sighted design considerations. I was curious if any of you had some pet peeves from a design perspective to rant about. I'll start with a couple. Here are a few of mine: The little clippy widgets (looks

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Matthew S. Hallacy
On Thu, Sep 18, 2003 at 03:53:44PM -0700, Ben Browning wrote: Procurve switch management interface. Archaic, arcane, insane, unusable. I'm actually quite happy with the HP ProCurve switch interface, the web interface is the first thing to be disabled though. -- Matthew S. Hallacy

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Scott Granados
Your all missing my most favorite bad design decision. And I know that in other areas this has been mentioned and made fun of enough but ... Who thought it was a good idea to put braille on the drive up atms? And having a contact in banking I do know that banks pay extra for this feature its

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread bmanning
The US Congress. can you say ADA - sure you can - Fred Rodgers Who thought it was a good idea to put braille on the drive up atms? --bill (sorry ren, I couldn't resist)

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Paul Timmins
I'm still trying to find out the point of labeling the light switches in airplanes. I can see the point of doing it if the button is obvious to the touch, but on some planes they use membrane switches that aren't obvious to the touch. I know the ADA probably requires them to label light switches,

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread JC Dill
At 04:24 PM 9/18/2003, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The US Congress. can you say ADA - sure you can - Fred Rodgers Who thought it was a good idea to put braille on the drive up atms? While I don't know if the person in question was blind or not, I *have* seen someone use a drive-up ATM from the

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Ben Browning [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: The little clippy widgets (looks kind of like @) on some oldschool racks, that hold the nut in place for the hex-head bolt. Why these were considered desirable is beyond me. We've got a bunch of racks like that (and my PDP8 rack at home

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-18 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Thu, 18 Sep 2003 16:14:39 PDT, Scott Granados said: Who thought it was a good idea to put braille on the drive up atms? My dad's legally blind. That braille makes it possible for him to get cash (either from the back seat or step out and walk up) if somebody's giving him a ride, without

Re: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-17 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Wed, 17 Sep 2003 17:43:24 CDT, Matt [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: I've got a couple others in my head from 3Com and a couple of others, but I thought I'd get the ball rolling. So, what do you think? Well.. maybe it's just still fresh in my memory and the aggravation factor is higher because of

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-17 Thread Shawn Solomon
The 12016 does have handles on the sides, but the documentation states not to use them for lifting purposes. Yeah, I laughed too, just before realizing that bear-hugging a 16 into position takes a bit of motivation. It is definitely one big hunk of iron (300+lbs on the shipping invoice), but I

RE: Worst design decisions?

2003-09-17 Thread Casassa, Nathan
: Worst design decisions? The 12016 does have handles on the sides, but the documentation states not to use them for lifting purposes. Yeah, I laughed too, just before realizing that bear-hugging a 16 into position takes a bit of motivation. It is definitely one big hunk of iron (300+lbs