Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-07-10 Thread Marc Kleine-Budde
On 06/29/2017 05:41 PM, Andrew Lunn wrote: >> Transceivers for CAN are not apart of any model. Traditional CAN didn't >> have a problem because all transceivers from my understanding supported >> the maximum speed of 1 Mbps defined by the spec. However, with the >> introduction of CAN Flexible Data

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-30 Thread Franklin S Cooper Jr
Hi Kurt, On 06/30/2017 03:09 AM, Kurt Van Dijck wrote: >> On 06/29/2017 05:36 PM, Kurt Van Dijck wrote: >> >> mcan@0 { >> ... >> fixed-transceiver { >>max-canfd-speed = <2000> >> }; >> ... >> }; >>> >>> Since when would a transceiver support different sp

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-30 Thread Kurt Van Dijck
> On 06/29/2017 05:36 PM, Kurt Van Dijck wrote: > > mcan@0 { > ... > fixed-transceiver { > max-canfd-speed = <2000> > }; > ... > }; > > > > Since when would a transceiver support different speeds for CAN & CANFD? > > When I say CAN I'm referring

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Franklin S Cooper Jr
On 06/29/2017 05:36 PM, Kurt Van Dijck wrote: mcan@0 { ... fixed-transceiver { max-canfd-speed = <2000> }; ... }; > > Since when would a transceiver support different speeds for CAN & CANFD? When I say CAN I'm referring to CAN 2.0 spe

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Kurt Van Dijck
> >> > >> mcan@0 { > >>... > >>fixed-transceiver { > >> max-canfd-speed = <2000> > >>}; > >>... > >> }; Since when would a transceiver support different speeds for CAN & CANFD? No transceivers were available, but they are now. I see no datalink problem applying 2MBit for r

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Andrew Lunn
> Also I agree that attempting to make this optional property/subnode > generic to all of CAN would be preferable. Another not sure if its > feasible yet without standardization being first forced across all CAN > drivers. It should be. All you need to do is add an of_get_can_maxspeed(struct devic

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Franklin S Cooper Jr
+device tree mailing list Hi Andrew On 06/29/2017 10:41 AM, Andrew Lunn wrote: >> Transceivers for CAN are not apart of any model. Traditional CAN didn't >> have a problem because all transceivers from my understanding supported >> the maximum speed of 1 Mbps defined by the spec. However, with the

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Andrew Lunn
> Transceivers for CAN are not apart of any model. Traditional CAN didn't > have a problem because all transceivers from my understanding supported > the maximum speed of 1 Mbps defined by the spec. However, with the > introduction of CAN Flexible Datarate mode it seems that for > transceivers that

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Franklin S Cooper Jr
Hi Andrew On 06/29/2017 09:21 AM, Andrew Lunn wrote: > On Wed, Jun 28, 2017 at 05:14:42PM -0500, Franklin S Cooper Jr wrote: >> Hi All, >> >> The various CAN transceivers I've seen that support CAN-FD appear to be >> fairly limited in terms of their supported max speed. I've seen some >> transceiv

Re: CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-29 Thread Andrew Lunn
On Wed, Jun 28, 2017 at 05:14:42PM -0500, Franklin S Cooper Jr wrote: > Hi All, > > The various CAN transceivers I've seen that support CAN-FD appear to be > fairly limited in terms of their supported max speed. I've seen some > transceivers that only support upto 2 Mbps while others support up to

CAN-FD Transceiver Limitations

2017-06-28 Thread Franklin S Cooper Jr
Hi All, The various CAN transceivers I've seen that support CAN-FD appear to be fairly limited in terms of their supported max speed. I've seen some transceivers that only support upto 2 Mbps while others support up to 5 Mbps. This is a problem when the SoC's CAN IP can support even higher values