Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...? [ZD1211]

2006-01-12 Thread Phil Dibowitz
Thanks for stepping up John. I'm really new to the netdev area, but I thought I'd throw this out as I've been watching this thread with interest... The GPL Realtek driver Andrea Merello: http://rtl8180-sa2400.sourceforge.net/ and

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...? [ZD1211]

2006-01-12 Thread Daniel Drake
Ulrich Kunitz wrote: I'm also working since a few weeks on a rewrite of the ZD1211. I'm a little bit more progressed than you, because my driver already loads the firmware and I'm able to set and read registers and I have the initialization code done. Thats almost exactly the stage we are at.

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...? [ZD1211]

2006-01-12 Thread Simon Kelley
Phil Dibowitz wrote: Thanks for stepping up John. I'm really new to the netdev area, but I thought I'd throw this out as I've been watching this thread with interest... The GPL Realtek driver Andrea Merello: http://rtl8180-sa2400.sourceforge.net/ and

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-11 Thread Jeff Garzik
John W. Linville wrote: I realize there are some burning issues at the moment, especially the DeviceScape vs. ieee80211 stack wars. I do not intend to pronounce summary judgment on any issues here or in the immediate future. Please do copy me on any important discussions, and feel free to

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-11 Thread Bas Vermeulen
On Tue, 2006-01-10 at 21:05 -0500, John W. Linville wrote: If you are the maintainer of an out-of-tree driver or other component (e.g. softmac), please let me hear from you (publicly or privately). I want to be sure to identify all the major stakeholders. I would also like to hear your plans

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-11 Thread Jean Tourrilhes
John W. Linville wrote : If you are the maintainer of an out-of-tree driver or other component (e.g. softmac), please let me hear from you (publicly or privately). Complete and up to date list of driver and their contact person is, and always has been, in the Linux WLAN Howto. As many

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-11 Thread Daniel Drake
John W. Linville wrote: If you are the maintainer of an out-of-tree driver or other component (e.g. softmac), please let me hear from you (publicly or privately). I want to be sure to identify all the major stakeholders. I would also like to hear your plans for getting your code into the

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-11 Thread Jeff Garzik
Daniel Drake wrote: FWIW, my opinion is that the devicescape code should be broken down and used to extend the existing stack, no matter how 'good' it is. The way it has been developed (i.e. totally outside of the ieee80211 stack) is somewhat insulting to our development process. Strongly

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...? [ZD1211]

2006-01-11 Thread Ulrich Kunitz
Hi, I'm also working since a few weeks on a rewrite of the ZD1211. I'm a little bit more progressed than you, because my driver already loads the firmware and I'm able to set and read registers and I have the initialization code done. The next step is reading (scanninng) a beacon frame. So

Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-10 Thread John W. Linville
A few days ago, Jeff Garzik reminded us all of the grossly imperfect state of wireless (802.11 aka WiFi) networking in Linux. First in his list of key issues was the lack of a permanent maintainer for the kernel wireless code. Jeff approached me to see if I was interested in that role, and after

Re: Wireless: One small step towards a more perfect union...?

2006-01-10 Thread David S. Miller
From: John W. Linville [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Tue, 10 Jan 2006 21:05:36 -0500 I hereby claim responsibility for the state of wireless networking support in the Linux kernel. Thanks for taking on this important role John. It is truly appreciated. Even though it may end up feeling like a