Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread Keith Hart
At last an oped piece from a former Leave staffer that at leas holds out the hope that one of Johnson, Gove, Davies et al will not succeed May as PM. THAT would be a true Brexit dividend. "In the end, the hard Brexiteer perfectionists bedazzled by cake and unicorns proved to be the obstacle that

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread James Wallbank
Hi David, Absolutely! But even with a slim majority, I don't believe that this policy could be pushed through Parliament. On current voting patterns, May would have lost the Meaningful Vote vote by around 50 even if she had 50 entirely biddable MPs at her disposal. All the best, James On

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread David Garcia
Hi James, I agree with all your points except: > I'm of almost exactly the opposite view to you, in that I'd say that this > shit-storm has demonstrated that Parliament absolutely is sovereign. > > The fact that the executive needs, deceptively, to propose cunningly > ambiguous forms of

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread James Wallbank
Hello David, The Brexit situation is indeed extraordinary, and it has thrown up deep deficiencies in the UK's constitutional arrangements, electoral security and, more widely, in its national identity. For what it's worth, my money, should I care to bet on it, would be that the UK will end

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread Keith Hart
Hi David, Thanks for that thoughtful response which justifiably raises longer term issues of the British constitution than the daily news as reported in the piece just sent in. I met the US ambassador to France in the year the euro was launched as currency and he asked me if Blair would buy into

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread David Garcia
Hi Keith I think the article is interesting but misses out the central challenge that the profound political/constitutional crisis has thrown up which is: at what point and how does a theoretically sovereign parliament take control when a government has lost control of events but is

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-13 Thread Keith Hart
On Mon, Mar 11, 2019 at 12:42 PM David Garcia < d.gar...@new-tactical-research.co.uk> wrote: > A true Democracy: All United in Ignorance- > Total fucking insanity > When asked by what is actually happening my reply has become “I know > nothing!” > There are a few people who have not abandoned

Re: At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-11 Thread Patrice Riemens
Hi David et All, I am really happy that you took over from me as Brexistan War Correspondant! The situation is indeed most desperate. We are now waiting for 'the telegram from Sadova' ... 30st of March will be a very special day - or a complete anti-climax. I am still hoping for the latter

At last the brexit dividend

2019-03-11 Thread David Garcia
A true Democracy: All United in Ignorance- Despite promises that this would be the ‘crunch week’ when the second “meaningful (HA!) vote" was to be held. It is looking increasingly likely that despite solumn promises the Olympic level can-kicker May will again defer the vote replacing it with