[NSP] Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Inky- Adrian
The new facebook forum The Proper Northumberland small-pipe Players has now developed into an array of topics: Traditional reedmaking, smallpipe making , traditional developement and delving into the past to see how things might have worked and possibly revamp them for todays use.

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Richard Shuttleworth
Dear Adrian, Why cannot all this very positive work be done on the current group that Wayne Cripps set up many years ago for exactly this type of discussion? Richard - Original Message - From: Inky- Adrian inkyadr...@googlemail.com To: nsp@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Friday, May 27,

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Richard Evans
-Original Message- From: Richard Shuttleworth Dear Adrian, Why cannot all this very positive work be done on the current group that Wayne Cripps set up many years ago for exactly this type of discussion? I agree totally- it all sounds very interesting but there's no way I'm going to

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Francis Wood
Hi Richards (both of you good folk!) I rather agree with Adrian that this kind of discussion is best held in a dedicated area. Some people are passionately interested in this aspect of piping, whilst others will find it totally boring. The problem with Dartmouth is that it is very difficult

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Julia Say
On 27 May 2011, Francis Wood wrote: this kind of discussion is best held in a dedicated area. Perhaps the best destination for this interesting discussion is a dedicated area of an already existing forum. Peacock's Parlour perhaps? http://www.northumbrianpipers.org.uk/pipersforum/ is

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread smallpipes
I agree with both Francis and Julia. A good, well run, forum is a great and flexible tool for the discussion of all matters piping. I have been a member of a number of forums for my other interests and compared with the mailing list style of interaction there is no comparison. I have

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Richard Evans
Mike is right about the value of a forum as compared to a list. There are a couple of uilleann pipes forums which each contain a superb archive of discussion and information going back several years. Easily searchable. And no need to join Facebook! Cheers Richard Richard Evans To get on

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread Tim Rolls
Hi All, When you register on the northumbrianpipers.org.uk/pipersforum/, please use a recognisable version of your own name. Problems in the past with aliases have led us to request this transparency. Thanks Tim nps forum admin On 27 May 2011, at 19:35, Julia Say wrote: On 27 May 2011,

[NSP] Re: Dartmouth

2011-05-27 Thread John Dally
Hopefully the new forum has spell-check as well. ;-) On Fri, May 27, 2011 at 1:39 PM, Inky- Adrian [1]inkyadr...@googlemail.com wrote: Dear all , If you don't like it, lump it. I'm buggering of to a more pleasant forum where we have intelligentcia.

[NSP] Rules

2011-05-27 Thread Inky- Adrian
I don't want a definate rule I would just like thr NPS to acknowledge that there is a traditional way of playing the small-pipes which is detached. If they don' t, then they are saying that the pipes have no playing tradition, therefore I'm playing pipes which are a bastard- no

[NSP] Re: Rules

2011-05-27 Thread Julia Say
On 27 May 2011, Inky- Adrian wrote: I don't want a definate rule I would just like thr NPS to acknowledge that there is a traditional way of playing the small-pipes which is detached. If they don' t, then they are saying that the pipes have no playing tradition, therefore I'm

[NSP] Re: Proper piping group

2011-05-27 Thread John Dally
Would it be possible to have a forum on the pipersfourm dedicated to TOTM? There might only be two of us interested in it, in which case it might as well stay here--no need to make more work for Julia. I hoped that pipers like Inky would participate so that they can show us what

[NSP] Re: Rules

2011-05-27 Thread barry07
I think Adrian is expressing some of my personal opinion. I think that the NPS has a significant duty to provide information to its membership, particularly new pipers, about the various approaches to piping and to offer encouragement to those who wish to take a disciplined approach to

[NSP] Re: Rules

2011-05-27 Thread Ian Lawther
barr...@nspipes.co.uk wrote: We have a strong piping community We have a viable society Several years ago I read a review of the first 25 or 30 years (forget which) of Na Piobairi Uilleann written by Pat McNulty in an Irish music magazine. His final comment stuck with meThere are more

[NSP] Re: Dartmouth

2011-05-27 Thread cwh...@santa-fe.freeserve.co.uk
--Boundary-00=_PLPVYHI1VA40 Content-Type: Text/Plain; charset=iso-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable I learned something today. Having written a rather large reply to this thread (probably shouldn't have bothered) I got a message saying it was waiting a mods