Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Stan Rivett
Afternoon all Thanks for all the advice, off and on-list. I'm a lot closer to a solution that will allow me to keep some food on the table ;-) I now owe a substantial quantity of beer to the group. Cheers Stan Rivett -- Netspeed PO Box 5691 Dunedin P: +64 3 481 7245 C: +64 21

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Nathan Ward
> On 8/11/2017, at 11:01 AM, Stan Rivett wrote: > > Hi all > > The time has come to replace my poor old Cisco 7301 and the quote I got for > an ASR1002-HX made my eyes water. Still waiting for a Juniper quote but the > general discussion seemed like similar numbers. >

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Dave Mill
Keep the bare minimum in your igp as Nathan says. It’s a pain in the arse to undo later says the person who’s been undoing it for years. Dave On Fri, 10 Nov 2017 at 3:02 PM, Tim Price wrote: > Two Nathans fighting on NZNOG, who will win? News at 11. > > > > *From:

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Nathan Ward
I don’t know about fighting. I disagree with your advice, and am cautioning others before they take it - people other than the OP will be learning from this thread. :-) > On 10/11/2017, at 2:58 PM, Nathan Brookfield > wrote: > > I don’t know why you’re

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Tim Price
Two Nathans fighting on NZNOG, who will win?  News at 11. From: on behalf of Nathan Brookfield Date: Friday, 10 November 2017 at 2:58 PM To: Nathan Ward Cc: nznog Subject: Re:

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Nathan Ward
One expects that BGP is already in place there - why complicate it by having some routes in OSPF and some in BGP, then have to re-arrange things when your network grows? Very common small ISP mistake that can be a PITA to correct when you’re 5 times the size (as everyone hopes to be) and

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Nathan Ward
Don’t do that. Put customer routes in to BGP, use OSPF only to carry your loopbacks and router-router links for iBGP to use. Keep your OSPF small, and your BGP big - it’s what they’re both good at. (OSPF and ISIS are interchangeable here) > On 10/11/2017, at 2:45 PM, Nathan Brookfield >

Re: [nznog] BRAS Options

2017-11-09 Thread Nathan Brookfield
Just running OSPF between them all wouldn’t solve that problem for you and worst case MPLS within a VRF? Kindest Regards, Nathan Brookfield (VK2NAB) Chief Executive Officer Simtronic Technologies Pty Ltd Local: (02) 4749 4949 | Fax: (02) 4749 4950 | Direct: (02) 4749 4951 Web: