RE: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: Yes -Original Message- From: Guru Sent: Tuesday, April 03, 2018 2:12 PM To: Kevin Rushforth <kevin.rushfo...@oracle.com> Cc: openjfx-dev@openjdk.java.net Subject: Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath Vote: YES > On 29-Mar-2018, at 10:12 PM, Kevin Rushforth <

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: YES > On 29-Mar-2018, at 10:12 PM, Kevin Rushforth > wrote: > > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 17 > changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. > > Votes are due by April 12,

RE: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: Yes Regards, Ajit -Original Message- From: Kevin Rushforth Sent: Thursday, March 29, 2018 10:12 PM To: openjfx-dev@openjdk.java.net; Rajath Kamath Subject: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: Yes --Ankit On Thu, Mar 29, 2018 at 11:11 PM, Kevin Rushforth < kevin.rushfo...@oracle.com> wrote: > I note that this vote is not valid. Only existing OpenJFX Project > Committers are eligible to vote. > > Thanks. > > -- Kevin > > > Shiv Kumar Ganesh wrote: > >> VOTE: yes >> >> On Thu,

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: yes -phil.

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

I note that this vote is not valid. Only existing OpenJFX Project Committers are eligible to vote. Thanks. -- Kevin Shiv Kumar Ganesh wrote: VOTE: yes On Thu, Mar 29, 2018, 10:23 AM Arunprasad Rajkumar > wrote:

RE: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

VOTE: YES > On 29-Mar-2018, at 10:12 PM, Kevin Rushforth > wrote: > > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 17 > changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. > > Votes are due by April 12,

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

VOTE: yes On Thu, Mar 29, 2018, 10:23 AM Arunprasad Rajkumar < arunprasad.rajku...@oracle.com> wrote: > VOTE: Yes > > > On 29-Mar-2018, at 10:12 PM, Kevin Rushforth > wrote: > > > > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > > > Rajath is a member

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

VOTE: Yes > On 29-Mar-2018, at 10:12 PM, Kevin Rushforth > wrote: > > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 17 > changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. > > Votes are due by April 12,

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: YES Kevin Rushforth wrote: I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 17 changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. Votes are due by April 12, 2018. Only current OpenJFX Committers [4] are eligible to vote on this

CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 17 changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. Votes are due by April 12, 2018. Only current OpenJFX Committers [4] are eligible to vote on this nomination. Votes must be cast in the

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Hi Ankit, If you read my response to your first email, I thought I was clear that we don't count test bugs the same as product fixes, but neither are they worth 0. Meaning that a few test fixes can certainly count towards "making up the difference" as I said. As for your two other points:

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Ankit, You should zoom out a little bit and look at the bigger picture. Does OpenJFX want more or less contributors? Does OpenJFX want to make the burden to becoming a committer easier or more difficult? Does OpenJFX want to be a community that welcomes or shuns people who are ready to

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

I have no idea when/why test bugs started to get counted for committer status. The last time I checked, number of lines of patch matters the most irrespective of the significance of the patch [ that was a very strange and funny way of judging a patch, must be an idea from a non technical person].

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Dear Kevin, I will get back to you on this shortly with substantial claims. --Ankit On 28 Feb 2018 2:23 a.m., "Kevin Rushforth" wrote: > Hi Ankit, > > In response to your veto, I took the opportunity to look at the the list > of changes, and believe that my

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Hi Ankit, In response to your veto, I took the opportunity to look at the the list of changes, and believe that my earlier nomination of Rajath to OpenJFX Project Committer was justified, if perhaps barely so. While there is no objective criteria by which one can say a particular changeset

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

NO, Please go through the table, all the points accumulated are not even more then 7. I have given reasons for my points. *age* *author* *description* Points Reason 8 days ago rkamath 8196802: 3D unit tests listed as pass although they are actually skipped

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: yes --Semyon On 02/12/2018 02:02 PM, Kevin Rushforth wrote: I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 11 changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. Votes are due by February 26, 2018. Only current OpenJFX

RE: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: Yes -Original Message- From: Kevin Rushforth Sent: Tuesday, February 13, 2018 3:32 AM To: Rajath Kamath <rajath.kam...@oracle.com>; openjfx-dev@openjdk.java.net Subject: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer.

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: YES > On 13-Feb-2018, at 3:32 AM, Kevin Rushforth > wrote: > > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 11 > changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. > > Votes are due by February

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: YES Kevin Rushforth wrote: > I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. > > Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 11 > changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. > > Votes are due by February 26, 2018. > > Only current OpenJFX Committers [4] are eligible to

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: yes -phil.

Re: CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

Vote: YES Kevin Rushforth wrote: I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 11 changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. Votes are due by February 26, 2018. Only current OpenJFX Committers [4] are eligible to vote on this

CFV: New OpenJFX Committer: Rajath Kamath

I hereby nominate Rajath Kamath [1] to OpenJFX Committer. Rajath is a member of JavaFX team at Oracle, who has contributed 11 changesets [2][3] to OpenJFX. Votes are due by February 26, 2018. Only current OpenJFX Committers [4] are eligible to vote on this nomination. Votes must be cast in