Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-12 Thread Jon Trulson
On Sat, 10 May 2008, GNU Watch wrote: I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Many developers dont want to invest time to opensolaris until it is under the GPLv3 because the CDDL doesnt

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-12 Thread Dale Ghent
I searched and search and found nowhere where Jonathan or anyone said that they would promise that OpenSolaris would be released under GPLv.anything. All I see in the URLs you reference is hearsay from sloppy tech journalists. So if no promise was made, how would it be broken? It may be

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-12 Thread GNU Watch
well I am not going to post any more responses in reguards to this thread i started as a mater of fact this will be my last thread. I just wanted to get feed back from others to see how you all feel. I hold you all with the up most respect and appreciate the overwelming feedback. Even though

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Alan Coopersmith
GNU Watch wrote: I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Many developers dont want to invest time to opensolaris until it is under the GPLv3 because the CDDL doesnt protect users and

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Joerg Schilling
GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Many developers dont want to invest time to opensolaris until it is under the GPLv3 because the CDDL doesnt

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Mario Goebbels
Now let's stop this thread, it will not help us. I can't even believe that anyone's arguing at all about this. Why? Take a look: GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: -mg ___ opensolaris-discuss mailing list opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Joerg Schilling
GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: hey Shawn this promise was made over a year ago by Jonathan Schwartz and Rich Green. The statement soon retracted by them which I understand bro but they clearly said they are strongly considering it and there has been no progress in that direction.

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Joerg Schilling
Mario Goebbels [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Now let's stop this thread, it will not help us. I can't even believe that anyone's arguing at all about this. Why? Take a look: GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For this reason, I mentioned that OpenSolaris contributors are known persons ;-)

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread Tim Scanlon
The GPL is crap, I hope to god it doesn't get used. Corporations violate it all the time, developers don't bother to read it, and it's an awful license to use if you want to feed yourself with your efforts. It mixes politics with business for people with too little balls to act politically.

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-11 Thread James Mansion
Tim Scanlon wrote: The GPL is crap, I hope to god it doesn't get used. Corporations violate it all the time, developers don't bother to read it, and it's an awful license to use if you want to feed yourself with your efforts. The thing I find mot odd about GPL is that if you work in a

[osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread GNU Watch
I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Many developers dont want to invest time to opensolaris until it is under the GPLv3 because the CDDL doesnt protect users and developers freedoms as

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Shawn Walker
On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 9:10 PM, GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Many developers dont want to invest time to opensolaris until it is under the

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread GNU Watch
hey Shawn this promise was made over a year ago by Jonathan Schwartz and Rich Green. The statement soon retracted by them which I understand bro but they clearly said they are strongly considering it and there has been no progress in that direction. Hey I appreciate your reply and dont mean

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Ian Collins
GNU Watch wrote: I have heard nothing but broken promises from Ian Murdock and other big whigs at sun saying that opensolaris will be released under the GPLv3. Please don't try and start another license war. If there ever was a promise, kindly quote it and not some second hand reference to

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread GNU Watch
hey ian take it easy no one wants to start a licence war with you. I am just trying to get feedback from the opensolaris community. This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ opensolaris-discuss mailing list opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Shawn Walker
On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 10:41 PM, GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: hey ian take it easy no one wants to start a licence war with you. I am just trying to get feedback from the opensolaris community. The general consensus among the community has been that we don't want that license. We like

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Shawn Walker
On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 9:43 PM, GNU Watch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: hey Shawn this promise was made over a year ago by Jonathan Schwartz and Rich Green. The statement soon retracted by them which I understand bro but they clearly said they are strongly considering it and there has been no

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread GNU Watch
thats great advice shawn I send sun an email, sun need to promote you for your great feedback. This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ opensolaris-discuss mailing list opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Ian Collins
GNU Watch wrote: thats great advice shawn I send sun an email, sun need to promote you for your great feedback. What is? Please keep the context you are replying to. Ian ___ opensolaris-discuss mailing list opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org

Re: [osol-discuss] will opensolaris ever be released under the GPL?

2008-05-10 Thread Dr. Robert Pasken
Please don't feed the trolls This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ opensolaris-discuss mailing list opensolaris-discuss@opensolaris.org