Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-28 Thread Aaron Kulkis
John Andersen wrote: On Jan 25, 2008 8:15 AM, Philipp Thomas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I haven't tried with USB, but with any other boot media I've encountered. Nuff said. Presumably the OP wanted to boot some other OS off of the USB disk. You are going on about initrd like you ASSUME he

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-26 Thread Philipp Thomas
On Fri, 25 Jan 2008 22:22:04 -0800, John Andersen wrote: Say he has Windows on the USB device. Then what? You expect that to boot with linux drivers? Please get the context right. I answered to Aaron, not the OP, because it's not necessary to compile in drivers. I see no reason to expect

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-25 Thread Aaron Kulkis
John Andersen wrote: On Jan 24, 2008 4:33 AM, Bill Anderson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: To find the initrd and vmlinuz files, GRUB uses the BIOS. Consequently, if the BIOS doesn't allow booting from a USB port, then you can't boot directly to the USB drive. This might be true for some values

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-25 Thread Aaron Kulkis
John Andersen wrote: On Jan 24, 2008 9:29 AM, Philipp Thomas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: * Aaron Kulkis ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [20080124 11:23]: So, part of the solution is recompiling the kernel to include the USB module (and all the others which the USB module depends on). Nonsense! You add the

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-25 Thread John Andersen
On Jan 25, 2008 8:15 AM, Philipp Thomas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I haven't tried with USB, but with any other boot media I've encountered. Nuff said. Presumably the OP wanted to boot some other OS off of the USB disk. You are going on about initrd like you ASSUME he is going to boot linux

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-25 Thread Philipp Thomas
* John Andersen ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [20080124 23:05]: Have you actually DONE this? It sounds like speculation to me. How do you think your kernel boots, given that the ide/sata/scsi drivers and the drivers for the file system you use aren't compiled into the kernel? They're loaded via the

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread Aaron Kulkis
Greg Freemyer wrote: On Jan 23, 2008 3:22 PM, John Andersen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Jan 22, 2008 4:56 PM, David C. Rankin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Listmates, I can't recall who suggested it, Aaron or Patrick, but somebody made the suggestion to get a simple use to ide adapter to

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread Bill Anderson
Greg Freemyer wrote: On Jan 23, 2008 3:22 PM, John Andersen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Jan 22, 2008 4:56 PM, David C. Rankin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Listmates, I can't recall who suggested it, Aaron or Patrick, but somebody made the suggestion to get a simple use to ide adapter

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread Lincoln Rutledge
Exactly. If grub loads from the usb device, it doesn't have to be told about the usb device. Chicken or egg thing. Lincoln Rutledge Network Engineer OSC Networking 800-627-6420 Bill Anderson [EMAIL PROTECTED] 01/24/08 7:33 AM Greg Freemyer wrote: On Jan 23, 2008 3:22 PM, John

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread Philipp Thomas
* Aaron Kulkis ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [20080124 11:23]: So, part of the solution is recompiling the kernel to include the USB module (and all the others which the USB module depends on). Nonsense! You add the necessary modules to INITRD_MODULES in /etc/sysconfig/kernel and then afterwards call

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread John Andersen
On Jan 24, 2008 4:33 AM, Bill Anderson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: To find the initrd and vmlinuz files, GRUB uses the BIOS. Consequently, if the BIOS doesn't allow booting from a USB port, then you can't boot directly to the USB drive. This might be true for some values of boot. Grub is

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-24 Thread John Andersen
On Jan 24, 2008 9:29 AM, Philipp Thomas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: * Aaron Kulkis ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) [20080124 11:23]: So, part of the solution is recompiling the kernel to include the USB module (and all the others which the USB module depends on). Nonsense! You add the necessary

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-23 Thread John Andersen
On Jan 22, 2008 4:56 PM, David C. Rankin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Listmates, I can't recall who suggested it, Aaron or Patrick, but somebody made the suggestion to get a simple use to ide adapter to access spare laptop drives, etc. Well, I purchased one, and it is absolutely the

Re: [opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-23 Thread Greg Freemyer
On Jan 23, 2008 3:22 PM, John Andersen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Jan 22, 2008 4:56 PM, David C. Rankin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Listmates, I can't recall who suggested it, Aaron or Patrick, but somebody made the suggestion to get a simple use to ide adapter to access spare

[opensuse] USB to ATA IDE Adapter, howto boot from it?

2008-01-22 Thread David C. Rankin
Listmates, I can't recall who suggested it, Aaron or Patrick, but somebody made the suggestion to get a simple use to ide adapter to access spare laptop drives, etc. Well, I purchased one, and it is absolutely the sharpest thing since sliced bread. I have several drives for my laptop and