Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-06-01 Thread dave
> -Original Message- > From: Victor Wagner [mailto:vi...@wagner.pp.ru] ... > > > > The OFB and CFB cipher modes in OpenVPN have not been > well-tested and > > should be considered experimental at this point. > > > > They are not compiled by default mostly to prevent someone from >

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-06-01 Thread dave
> -Original Message- > From: 'Victor Wagner' [mailto:vi...@wagner.pp.ru] ... > As far as I can see, openvpn can be thoroughly tested in automated > fashion. I have some test farm with half a hundred various > OSes (Linux, > Windows, Solaris, FreeBSD on several architectures), and

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-06-01 Thread 'Victor Wagner'
On 2009.06.01 at 07:45:13 -0500, dave wrote: > I would suspect that the exclusion is due to: > > A) in CFB/OFB/CNT, the encrypted stream is byte-bounded, as opposed to > block-bounded. There may be some assumptions in the code that assume > the cipher text is a multiple of block lengths. As

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-06-01 Thread Victor Wagner
On 2009.05.30 at 04:38:41 -0600, James Yonan wrote: > > The OFB and CFB cipher modes in OpenVPN have not been well-tested and > should be considered experimental at this point. > They are not compiled by default mostly to prevent someone from > accidentally using them. Okay, you see there

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-30 Thread James Yonan
Victor Wagner wrote: On 2009.05.27 at 10:48:30 -0700, Frank Yellin wrote: I posted the following onto the OpenVPN forum, but it was suggested that I would be better off mailing directly to this list. = I seem to have found a bug in 2.1_rc16 that is also

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-29 Thread Frank Yellin
A simpler way to see the crypto bug. . . . $ openvpn --secret static.key --test-crypto Fri May 29 10:56:58 2009 OpenVPN crypto self-test mode SUCCEEDED. $ openvpn --secret static.key --test-crypto --cipher bf-ofb Fri May 29 11:12:07 2009 OpenVPN 2.1_rc15 mipsel-unknown-linux-gnu [SSL]

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-28 Thread Victor Wagner
On 2009.05.27 at 23:17:39 -0700, Frank Yellin wrote: >[Just to you, not the list.] >I figured that someone had to have noticed this problem before. But >when I googled "OpenVPN BF-OFB" or "OpenVPN BF-CFB", I couldn't find >anything. Of course you haven't find anything about

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-28 Thread Frank Yellin
[Just to you, not the list.] I figured that someone had to have noticed this problem before. But when I googled "OpenVPN BF-OFB" or "OpenVPN BF-CFB", I couldn't find anything. This bug is particularly strange because just before the bug, there is code that's supposed to deal with -CFB and

Re: [Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-28 Thread Victor Wagner
On 2009.05.27 at 10:48:30 -0700, Frank Yellin wrote: >I posted the following onto the OpenVPN forum, but it was suggested >that I would be better off mailing directly to this list. >= >I seem to have found a bug in 2.1_rc16 that is also apparent in earlier

[Openvpn-devel] Unable to use -OFB or -CFB ciphers in OpenVPN

2009-05-27 Thread Frank Yellin
I posted the following onto the OpenVPN forum, but it was suggested that I would be better off mailing directly to this list. = I seem to have found a bug in 2.1_rc16 that is also apparent in earlier versions. Although OpenVPN claims to support -CFB and -OFB cipher modes,