Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-23 Thread Gerardo @neorigami.com
On May 5 I sent through the list my previous message regarding this thread. In it, I told you I decided to contact the creator (Víctor M. Nuñez) of the prior model ("Star bowl"), and discuss with him if my model was a variation of his own or not. So I thought about sharing the highlights of the co

Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-05 Thread Gerardo @neorigami.com
Regarding the discussion about what is a variation in origami and if my box is one or not, David Mitchell made a distinction between two concepts "variation" and "development". Thank you David! I loved the distinction and I think it's a very useful one. I understand that you coined the concept of

[Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-04 Thread David Mitchell
Gerardo wrote: >what makes a variation precisely a variation? I doubt there is any possibility of a precise answer. However, I always like to make a distinction between a variation and a development, a variation being a small change, such as opening a flap to create a colour change, which does n

Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-02 Thread Gerardo @neorigami.com
Dianne, suggested reading cases about copyright infringement and of fair use in order to understand better the concept of "variation" in regards to origami, and particularly in the case of the box I recently "created". Thanks again Dianne : ) I can understand how a case about origami "variations"

Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-02 Thread KDianne Stephens
When perusing (US) copyright infringement cases, significant difference (form, function etc.) is a critical deciding factor, albeit, often the path to decision can be somewhat subjective. Reading court cases can offer much insight on derivative works. Exploring fair use cases will be of value

Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-05-01 Thread Gerardo @neorigami.com
Yesterday I shared through the list a picture of a box I had "created", confessed I made it by tweaking a fold of Victor M. N. R.'s "Star Bowl", and mentioned it's similar appearance to tato boxes, like ones folded by Phillip Chapman-bell, Melisandé, and Jun Mitani. I then asked if it was a variati

Re: [Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-04-30 Thread KDianne Stephens
So I'm lost if it's a variation or not, and if it is a variation, of what original model. I really hope we can start a discussion from this case in order to learn more about such a common word in origami like "variation". I looked for a definition of the word in relation to origami, on the web and

[Origami] Is this a variation?

2017-04-30 Thread Gerardo @neorigami.com
I created this box I had already shown you: https://scontent-mia1-2.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/17884529_1683577301658241_8590564274241673726_n.jpg?oh=403cc2d806da9880a815ea84b3c7ee41&oe=598025B5 I created it when I started playing with a fold I had made of *Star Bowl* by Víctor M. N. R.: https://www.fl