Re: Givens   --  Again  : some comments

2004-11-22 Thread EVERETT813
In a message dated 11/19/04 3:24:47 PM, hho...@comcast.net writes: > Bob wrote: "Sometimes I'd rather be free to explore within a known boundary > than not know when I was going to drop off the edge of the > world." > > I guess I could say something like . . . only a flatlander worries about > f

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-22 Thread Peggy S. Holman
the space is too open. Ain't our diversity great? Peggy - Original Message - From: "Chris Corrigan" To: Sent: Monday, November 22, 2004 11:05 AM Subject: Re: [OSLIST] Givens -- Again : some comments On Mon, 22 Nov 2004 13:28:11 EST, everett...@aol.com wrote: 1.

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-22 Thread Chris Corrigan
On Mon, 22 Nov 2004 13:28:11 EST, everett...@aol.com wrote: > > 1. When an ant carrying a stick comes to another stick, it puts its stick > down. > 2. When an ant not carrying a stick comes to a stick, it picks the stick > up (and carries it until rule 1 occurs). > > That will build an ant h

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-21 Thread Funda Oral
- Original Message - From: "Artur Silva" To: Sent: Saturday, November 20, 2004 8:51 PM Subject: Re: Givens -- Again : some comments > Thanks, for speaking up, Chris. > > > --- chris weaver wrote: > > So, Artur, Harrison, et al: Does this hurt the >

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-20 Thread Chris Corrigan
In a complicated way, I think givens can be very empowering. But they have to be real givens. I think the last time I talked about this a couple of years ago, I used the story of people inventing the airplane. The Wright brothers had a good sense of the givens of flight: gravity, air pressure, l

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-20 Thread Doris Gottlieb
form part of this context Doris (an avid reader and not often writer) -Oorspronkelijk bericht- Van: OSLIST [mailto:osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu]Namens Bob Dick Verzonden: vrijdag 19 november 2004 23:43 Aan: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Onderwerp: Re: Givens -- Again : some

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-20 Thread Artur Silva
Thanks, for speaking up, Chris. --- chris weaver wrote: > So, Artur, Harrison, et al: Does this hurt the > event? Does this disrespect > the people? No, I don't think it does and (if I understood well) it is even an interesting way to make some previous undiscussable ideas of the sponsor disc

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-20 Thread Bob Dick
Fascinating discussion. I don't think givens are always useless. I do agree that they can limit creativity and exploration. I also think there is another aspect to the issue. Sometimes I'd rather be free to explore within a known boundary than not know when I was going to drop off the edge of t

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-19 Thread Harrison Owen
ehalf Of Bob Dick Sent: Friday, November 19, 2004 5:43 PM To: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Subject: Re: Givens -- Again : some comments Fascinating discussion. I don't think givens are always useless. I do agree that they can limit creativity and exploration. I also think there is another aspect

Re: Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-19 Thread chris weaver
te deeper understanding, and to facilitate a smooth and powerful integration of the OST event into the realities of the ongoing work. My two cents! Thanks, Artur, for flushing me out ;-) Chris As OST facilitators, > From: Artur Silva > Reply-To: OSLIST > Date: Fri, 19 Nov 2004 11:32:09 -080

Givens -- Again : some comments

2004-11-19 Thread Artur Silva
Hi all: What I find interesting is that everyone that spoke this time seems to be in accordance that "givens" are useless (with some minor observations of caution, in some cases). This compares with the big discussions in the previous times the question was raised. Of course, I am happy that now