Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread Christian
John Francis wrote: On Mon, Jan 07, 2008 at 03:47:06PM -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Sky's interesting, as it's a straight rebadge of the Opel Speedster (Same styling and drivetrain) unlike the fairly extensively modified Solstice (which is based on the Speedster, but not identical).

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread P. J. Alling
I believe it was a home grown abomination. Christian wrote: John Francis wrote: On Mon, Jan 07, 2008 at 03:47:06PM -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Sky's interesting, as it's a straight rebadge of the Opel Speedster (Same styling and drivetrain) unlike the fairly extensively

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread Christian
Christian wrote: Wasn't the Aztek another Opel derivative? P. J. Alling wrote: I believe it was a home grown abomination. Yeah, I just googled it AFTER I sent my message to the list... The Aztek had among the highest CSI (Customer Satisfaction Index) scores in its class, and won the

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread P. J. Alling
GM should have given up on attempting styling with the Buick Roadmaster Stationwagon of 1991-96. Probably they should have given up before that, but the Roadmaster, (or as I always thought of it the :Toadmaster, should have capped it). Christian wrote: Christian wrote: Wasn't the

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread pnstenquist
And they're doing good work today. GM car designs come from all over the world. The newest Cadillacs have won several international awards, and I expect the Impala will do likewise. The latest Corvette is quite nice as well. Some, like Pontiac, are targeted at a demographic that is less

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread pnstenquist
I high CSI score only means that the people who bought it like it. From all the reports I've heard, it was a high quality vehicle. I believe it's the same platform as the Buick Renegade. Unfortunately, the styling didn't have broad appeal. I found it butt ugly. Paul -- Original

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread Adam Maas
Saturn was a market failure and the changes were driven by its effective elimination from viability by 2003. It is now effectively the replacement for Oldsmobile in market segment and is selling far better than it ever did when semi-independant. -Adam On 1/8/08, P. J. Alling [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread Adam Maas
Same platform as the even uglier Buick Rendevous. At least the Aztek looked unique. But owners seem to love the things, ugly as they are. Very practical vehicle. I'd consider owning one, they get decent mileage, are surprisingly reliable for a Pontiac, have plenty of space, some nice features

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-08 Thread P. J. Alling
Saturn was a market failure because GM management, after Roger Smith left the chairmanship, starved if of capitol. The original cars sold well. Much of like Pentax, Saturn sold as many units as they could produce, but they could never produce enough units with just one plant, and no capital

OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-07 Thread ntax
The Saturn division originally built very good little cars, a great first cut on subcompacts. GM simply starved them of money until they could be made over in the image of the parent company. Now Saturns are just plastic clad GM extrusions. They build keepers but the fish keeps rotting

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-07 Thread ntax
The Sky's interesting, as it's a straight rebadge of the Opel Speedster (Same styling and drivetrain) unlike the fairly extensively modified Solstice (which is based on the Speedster, but not identical). Wait, you mean the Sky and Solstice aren't the exact same rebadged car? Are you certain?

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-07 Thread Adam Maas
Opel has been a GM mark since 1931, apart from brief government control during the Nazi era. GM initially invested in Opel in 1929, buying 80%, and bought the rest in 1931. Several Opel designs have made it over here under different names, starting with the Cadillac Catera/Saturn L100. The Sky

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-07 Thread Adam Maas
Also, Saturn seems to be essentially the US branding for Opel as of this year, much as Vauxhall is in the UK and some low-end Holdens are in Australia. All of the current Saturn line are similar or identical to Opels but manufacture is shared. THe Astra and Sky/GT are identical, while the Aura and

Re: OT: Saturn (was Re: Question for automobile enthusiasts on the list)

2008-01-07 Thread John Francis
On Mon, Jan 07, 2008 at 03:47:06PM -0800, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Sky's interesting, as it's a straight rebadge of the Opel Speedster (Same styling and drivetrain) unlike the fairly extensively modified Solstice (which is based on the Speedster, but not identical). Wait, you mean