Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-09 Thread Joseph Tainter
Since one ideally uses a polarizer at a right angle to the sun, I have never been certain that adding coating to a polarizer accomplishes very much. I believe that Pentax does not add SMC coating to their polarizers, while they add SMC coating to nearly everything else that light goes through.

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-09 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
The purpose to applying an antireflection coating has nothing at all to do with the effects of a polarizing grid on light passing through it. Antireflection coatings reduce scatter at the air-glass interface, which causes flare. This is just as much a problem with a polarizing filter's

Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Igor Roshchin
Hello! I have a few questions about Multi-Coated circular polarizers. I am considering buying one for my SMCP F-70-210/4-5.6, FA 50/1.4 and future D-FA100/2.8. For other lenses I am using BW 77E slim c-polarizer which works fine on my both Tokinas. The only problem I have with it is that it is

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
Don't get the slim version, get the standard. Slim versions of filters generally dispense with most if not all of the front mounted threads to help prevent vignetting with short focal length lenses, which isn't a problem with portrait to tele lenses. G On May 8, 2007, at 1:52 PM, Igor

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Wilko Bulte
On Tue, May 08, 2007 at 04:52:41PM -0400, Igor Roshchin wrote.. Hello! I have a few questions about Multi-Coated circular polarizers. I am considering buying one for my SMCP F-70-210/4-5.6, FA 50/1.4 and future D-FA100/2.8. For other lenses I am using BW 77E slim c-polarizer which works

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Igor Roshchin
Yep. It is exactly why I bought the slim version: so that I can use it on Tokina 19-35 (yet with the film camera). It might have been an overkill, - but I definitely had no vignetting. :-) I am not looking for a slim version in this case: all the focal lengths are =50mm. Any recommendations on

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
B+W makes the best polarizers, and their mounts, MRC coatings are state of the art. I wouldn't consider anything else. G On May 8, 2007, at 2:12 PM, Igor Roshchin wrote: Yep. It is exactly why I bought the slim version: so that I can use it on Tokina 19-35 (yet with the film camera). It

Re: Question about MC circular polarizers

2007-05-08 Thread Sylwester Pietrzyk
On 2007-05-08, at 22:52, Igor Roshchin wrote: So, do you have any recommendations for a good quality polarizer that is not too expensive? Or even better - can you compare or point to a web-site that has comparison of different polarizer brands? If you have one that you've been considering to