[PEIRCE-L] Philosophies of Atomic Theory

2015-03-25 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
List: This website: http://www.eoht.info/page/Atomic+theory gives a short survey of atomism, from classic Greek philosophy to modern times, including its relation to sub-atomic physics. The stages of development of philosophical thought about the nature of matter are presented diagrammatical

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Philosophies of Atomic Theory

2015-03-25 Thread Gary Richmond
Jerry, list, Jerry, thanks for this very handy "survey of atomism," as you phrased it. As for Peirce being "a follower of Boscovich," there are only a very few mentions of him in the CP, mainly in relation to Kant's logic. There are some brief remarks on "Boschovichian points" in the 1898 Cambrid

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Philosophies of Atomic Theory

2015-03-25 Thread John Collier
Interesting, Jerry. The Scottish Common Sense philosophers (Thomas Reid and his followers) were Boscovichians, but they thought just that atoms were very small, not points, since one could not confirm they were points, but they acted like points, being very small. They were quite influential on

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Philosophies of Atomic Theory

2015-03-25 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
John, Steven, Gary: The critical role of Boscovich in CSP's scientific thinking is expressed very clearly in W8:284-285, in an article for Nation, entitled "The Periodic Law." In the last paragraph, he hypothesizes ... "it might be supposed that most of the existing chemical elements have be

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Philosophies of Atomic Theory

2015-03-25 Thread Steven Ericsson-Zenith
Charles' many appeals to the continuum and (essentially) deconstruction (the inverse of the constructive approach) suggest that his appeal to atomism and constructive approaches is exactly as his appeal is to evolution. IOW, atoms are ideas, in my terms "ways of speaking about the world," Charles'