Re: [PEIRCE-L] [biosemiotics:7252] Re: Natural Propositions Chapter 4

2014-11-03 Thread Edwina Taborsky
--- Original Message ----- From: Howard Pattee To: Frederik Stjernfelt ; Peirce List ; biosemiot...@lists.ut.ee Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2014 11:28 PM Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] [biosemiotics:7252] Re: Natural Propositions Chapter 4 At 02:45 PM 11/2/2014, Frederik Stjernfelt wrote:

Re: [PEIRCE-L] [biosemiotics:7252] Re: Natural Propositions Chapter 4

2014-11-03 Thread Sungchul Ji
Howard wrote: "I will add that genetic information is symbolic because (110214-1) the primary function necessary for life, which is self-replication, requires copying information without initiating its control function. That is, for self-replication, symbols must be copied and transmitted wit

Re: [PEIRCE-L] [biosemiotics:7252] Re: Natural Propositions Chapter 4

2014-11-02 Thread Howard Pattee
At 02:45 PM 11/2/2014, Frederik Stjernfelt wrote: Dear Howard, Gary, lists, I think Howard and myself are on the same main line here, even if not in all details. I think Howard's generalization of "language" goes too far because that seems to require an elaborated system to exist as a prerequ

Re: [PEIRCE-L] [biosemiotics:7252] Re: Natural Propositions Chapter 4

2014-11-02 Thread Frederik Stjernfelt
Dear Howard, Gary, lists, I think Howard and myself are on the same main line here, even if not in all details. I think Howard's generalization of "language" goes too far because that seems to require an elaborated system to exist as a prerequisite to even the very first occurrences of signs