Re: [biosemiotics:7066] RE: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-11 Thread Frederik Stjernfelt
Dear J, G, lists - I think Peirce primarily uses "intention" in the scholastic sense (first intention vs. second intention) where it does not yet have the psychological connotations it later achieved. I think J is right in taking "purpose" as the more general term - P did a similar thing when ta

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-03 Thread Clark Goble
> On Oct 3, 2014, at 2:28 PM, Gary Fuhrman wrote: > > I wasn't referring to intentionality in the sense of "aboutness", or to the > scholastic ideas of first and second intentions; I guess it's tautologically > true that informational signs must involve intentions in that sense. I’ve > often

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-03 Thread Gary Fuhrman
iosemiot...@lists.ut.ee; 'Peirce List' Subject: RE: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5 Hi Gary F., What is the difference between saying that every dicisign involves an intention, and saying that every dicisign involves (or is somehow related to) a purpose? My untutored assumpt

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-03 Thread Clark Goble
> On Oct 3, 2014, at 12:30 PM, Jeffrey Brian Downard > wrote: > > Perhaps we should distinguish between different ways that the word > 'intention' is used in Peirce's texts. There is the common meaning that is > expressed when I say, for instance, that my intention in writing the > sentence

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-03 Thread Jeffrey Brian Downard
ention, that would be good to spell out. --Jeff Jeff Downard Associate Professor Department of Philosophy NAU (o) 523-8354 From: Gary Fuhrman [g...@gnusystems.ca] Sent: Friday, October 03, 2014 8:48 AM To: biosemiot...@lists.ut.ee; 'Peirce List' Sub

[PEIRCE-L] Natural Propositions, Chapter 3.5

2014-10-03 Thread Gary Fuhrman
Section 3.5 of NP takes up "The Indexical Side of Dicisigns" by first showing the importance of (and the more recent terminology for) Peirce's advances in the algebra of logic which made it possible to separate the subject and predicate parts of the proposition, and thus the indexical and iconic pa