[PEIRCE-L] Re: Communicating an Idea (was commens and commons)

2020-06-21 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
List: After stating that "the only way of directly communicating an idea is by means of an icon" (R 787:23[27], CP 2.278), Peirce proceeds to describe algebraic formulae as "icons in which the likeness is aided by conventional rules" (23-24[27-28], 2.279-280). Near the end of the manuscript, he

[PEIRCE-L] Re: Communicating an Idea (was commens and commons)

2020-06-17 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
List: According to Peirce in this manuscript, each *index* in an assertion denotes one of its *subjects*, either by a word or by "a mere look or gesture" (R 787:19[23], CP 2.338, c. 1895-6). How we distinguish those subjects is somewhat arbitrary. CSP: Thus, in the assertion, "all men are