Re: Fast Track Down, Not Out/Progressive Populist 12/97

1997-12-02 Thread john gulick
At 07:09 PM 12/2/97 -0600, you wrote: >Not all of the Reform Party positions are compatible with >progressive populism. But progressive populists ought to work with the >Reformers on common issues such as opening the ballot to alternative >parties, campaign finance reform, fair trade laws and enc

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Tom Walker
Bill Lear wrote, >Although Anders, Doug, and Tom all object to Robin's passing on the >question of laws and enforcement, I sympathize somewhat with Robin's >position. To the extent that any of this can be planned in advance, >there is, or should be, a certain freedom to see things in separate >

Utopias + localism

1997-12-02 Thread R. Anders Schneiderman
At 01:53 PM 12/2/97 +, John wrote (replying to David): >>I would think that communities would control their basic needs and interests >>while joining in federations, both industrial and geographical, in order to >>take advantage of economies of scale. At least that seems to be the crux of >>

Re: Utopias + localism

1997-12-02 Thread Thomas Kruse
Wrote Anders: >And then there are countless examples of how local control can stomp on >minorities or dump a community's crap on its neighbors if it isn't strongly >counterbalanced by larger entities. So, what's so great about starting >locally, as opposed to starting locally _and_ regionally _a

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread john gulick
At 10:41 PM 12/1/97 -0800, you wrote: >John Gulick: >>what about the partial >>correlation between the production of surplus (and I'm not talking >>about superfluous luxury goods here) and increasingly sophisticated >>and specialized technical and industrial divisions of labor ? > >What about i

contingency

1997-12-02 Thread Doug Henwood
Continuing a discussion from several months ago, the opening of a BLS news release published today. The full text is on the BLS web site at http://stats.bls.gov/news.release/conemp.toc.htm. I welcome discussion as to what it all means. Doug Technical information: (202) 606-6378 USDL 97

Karl Marx: Western Europe is not a model

1997-12-02 Thread Louis N Proyect
Karl Marx: The chapter on primitive accumulation [in Marx's Capital] claims no more to trace the path by which, in Western Europe, the capitalist economic order emerged from the womb of the feudal economic order. It therefore presents the historical movement which, by divorcing the producers from

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread R. Anders Schneiderman
At 12:37 PM 12/2/97 -0500, you wrote: >One great thing about participatory planning is it eliminates the free >rider problem for expressing desires for public goods. What about other free rider problems? And how exactly does it eliminate the FR problem for expressing desires for public goods?

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread William S. Lear
On Tuesday, December 2 [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: > >but i want to know which of our current jobs are good ones, which >could be mde into good ones (for our future good society), which would >have to be eliminated altogether or done by machines, etc? Do you think a good first step would be to conc

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread MIKEY
friends, but i want to know which of our current jobs are good ones, wqhich could be mde into good ones (for our future good society), whihc would have to be eliminatedaltogether or done by machines, etc? michael yates

Re: Miscalculation

1997-12-02 Thread Doug Henwood
James Devine wrote: >(1) how does Shaikh measure the rate of profit? does he include the wages >of unproductive labor as part of the numerator, as he does in other >research? if so, I can't think of any reason why his "Marxian rate of >profit" (in Fred Moseley's terms) would be correlated with th

Global Warming

1997-12-02 Thread Mark Jones
Why is global warming the issue of issues? 1. The research shows that global warming as a result of greenhouse gas emissions is happening faster than was previously supposed; and that the ultimate effects will be determined by the rate of increase of greenhouse gas in the atmosphere as well as t

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Tom Walker
michael yates wrote, >but i want to know which of our current jobs are good ones, wqhich could be mde >into good ones (for our future good society), whihc would have to be >eliminatedaltogether or done by machines, etc? I suspect that most of the people on this list have jobs (or work) that th

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Robin Hahnel
William S. Lear wrote: > > On Mon, December 1, 1997 at 15:36:55 (-0800) Dave Markland writes: > >[Hahnel and Albert's] work (especially _Looking Forward: Participatory > >Economics in the 21st century_ and _The Political Economy of > >Participatory Economics_) examines the shortcomings of markets

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Doug Henwood
R. Anders Schneiderman wrote (responding to Robin Hahnel): >>One great thing about participatory planning is it eliminates the free >>rider problem for expressing desires for public goods. > >What about other free rider problems? And how exactly does it eliminate >the FR problem for expressing d

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread john gulick
At 08:11 PM 12/1/97 -0800, Michael Eisenscher wrote: >I spent part of the day looking for the entirety of that quote from Gompers, >but did not find it. I'm sure someone out there has it at hand. But I did >find the following Gompersian wisdom: >"The aim of our unions is to improve the standar

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Tom Walker
Robin Hahnel: >>>Enforcement? I'm an economist. Ask lawyers and criminologists about a >>>desirable system of law enforcement. (This reminds me of an old joke. The punch line is "You vant bread? Go bang a baker!") Anders Schneiderman: >>Er, no. If you're proposing this as a serious alternativ

Fast Track Down, Not Out/Progressive Populist 12/97

1997-12-02 Thread J Cullen
___ THE PROGRESSIVE POPULIST: A MONTHLY JOURNAL OF THE HEARTLAND December 1997 -- Volume 3, Number 12 ___ EDITORIAL Fast Track is Down, But the Game's Not Over The people won a round l

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread William S. Lear
On Tue, December 2, 1997 at 12:37:26 (-0500) Robin Hahnel writes: > >One great thing about participatory planning is it eliminates the free >rider problem for expressing desires for public goods. Laws? >Enforcement? I'm an economist. Ask lawyers and criminologists about a >desirable system of law

Discussion: The Limits Imposed Demand That The Working Class Acts In A New Way

1997-12-02 Thread Shawgi A. Tell
If workers shut down a factory or a whole sector of the economy in the course of waging the struggle for their rights they soon find that their struggle reaches the limits imposed by the capitalist system. These limits are based on the private ownership of property and the political power it wiel

Re: contingency

1997-12-02 Thread Tom Walker
Doug Henwood wrote, >Continuing a discussion from several months ago, the opening of a BLS news >release published today. The full text is on the BLS web site at >http://stats.bls.gov/news.release/conemp.toc.htm. This is good news. It gives the lie to hype about "job shift" and the "entrepreneur

Re: utopias

1997-12-02 Thread Michael Eisenscher
Perhaps I should have made the point explicit. Tom alluded to Gomper's oft cited speech in which he describes labor's aspirations as wanting "more." Rarely do those who use the reference actually provide the entire quote from which "more" is taken. I tried to dig it up, but could not. The quote

Re: More! More!

1997-12-02 Thread Michael Eisenscher
I am left architecturally speechless -- more or less. At 12:05 AM 12/3/97 -0800, Tom Walker wrote: >Michael Eisenscher wrote, > >>I spent part of the day looking for the entirety of that quote from Gompers, >>but did not find it. . . > >Mies van der Rohe is credited with having said "Less is mor