Charles and Race Theory 2
by Waistline2
27 May 2002 16:00 UTC
Melvin,
The shortest answer to all you say in these many, many posts is that "race" is a
historical category. Basically, my answers will focus on that. You are wrong when you
assert, argue, assume, insist, write at le
Charles and Race Theory 2
by Waistline2
29 May 2002 03:08 UTC
On Marxline you wrote"
>Melvin,
>The shortest answer to all you say in these many, many posts is that "race" is a
>>historical category. Basically, my answers will focus on that. You are wron
On Marxline you wrote"
>Melvin,
>The shortest answer to all you say in these many, many posts is that "race" is a >historical category. Basically, my answers will focus on that. You are wrong when >you assert, argue, assume, insist, write at length, that race is only a biological and >not a hist
Original Message-
From: Charles Brown [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Tuesday, May 28, 2002 3:33 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [PEN-L:26414] Charles and Race Theory 2
Charles and Race Theory 2
by Waistline2
27 May 2002 16:00 UTC
Melvin,
The shortest answer to all you say in these
- Original Message -
From: "Charles Brown" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> You are absolutely wrong. I assert that race is an ideological
category existing in the superstructure without a material reality.
===
Amen.
Ian
“Black and white, unite and fight!” is extremely disheartening to a man that believes in “Proletarians of the World Unite!, and “Workers and Oppressed People of the World Unite!,” which appears to perhaps be historically obsolete, given our current stage in the development of capital world wide.
hat it isn't
"real". Or that just because someone is anti-racist that they do not
benefit from their "whiteness" in a white supremacist society.
-Original Message-
From: Ian Murray [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Wednesday, May 29, 2002 5:19 PM
To: [EMAI
"Black and white, unite and fight!" is extremely disheartening to a man that believes in "Proletarians of the World Unite!, and "Workers and Oppressed People of the World Unite!," which appears to perhaps be historically obsolete, given our current stage in the development of capital world wide.
I think that this debate only involves Charles and Melvin. Should it not
be taken offline?
--
Michael Perelman
Economics Department
California State University
Chico, CA 95929
Tel. 530-898-5321
E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]