Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-23 Thread Robert Saute, CUNY Grad Center
Dear friends, Those who have been following Louis' posts on ecology will be interested in knowing that the 1998 Socialist Scholars Conference will feature a panel on "Marxist Contributions to Ecological Theory" with John Bellamy Foster, University of Oregon Stephen Jay

Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-22 Thread William S. Lear
On Sat, February 21, 1998 at 21:47:46 (-0500) Louis Proyect writes: The Fall 1996 Science and Society, edited by PEN-L'er David Laibman, contains an article by Douglas Boucher called "Not With a Bang, but a Whimper." It includes a paragraph that I find highly disturbing: As ecosystems are

Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-22 Thread Louis Proyect
Bill Lear: The scenario of every last species except homo sapiens becoming extinct would indeed be catastrophic, but I also see this as quite consistent with LL's comment about replacing one environment we like (this one, though we would like it better if we would stop "all the terrible things"

Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-22 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
I have not read either the Boucher article or the Levins and Lewontin piece in O'Connor's journal. But I think that they are being misinterpreted and unfairly castigated here. They are the authors of _The Dialectical Biologist_ and are both extremely capable ecologists. Levins is one

Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-22 Thread Louis N Proyect
On Sun, 22 Feb 1998, Rosser Jr, John Barkley wrote: I have not read either the Boucher article or the Levins and Lewontin piece in O'Connor's journal. But I think that they are being misinterpreted and unfairly castigated here. They are the authors of _The Dialectical The focus

Re: Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-22 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
Louis, My mail comes in in a funny order. I actually keep track of SS but somehow did not bother reading the Boucher piece in its original site. It isn't all that impressive I must say, especially in its political analysis which is somehwere between medieval and pathetic. I should

Ecology and value free Marxism

1998-02-21 Thread Louis Proyect
The Fall 1996 Science and Society, edited by PEN-L'er David Laibman, contains an article by Douglas Boucher called "Not With a Bang, but a Whimper." It includes a paragraph that I find highly disturbing: As ecosystems are transformed, species are eliminated -- but opportunities are created for