Proyect [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject:[PEN-L:35883] Re: Re: Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The
whole thing?
Send reply to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Michael Hoover:
What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research.
whatever gave you above idea?
I have
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35855] G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?
Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books. His theory's not very deep (in my humble opinion), but most of the people on pen-l
PROTECTED] http://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~jdevine
stop the war now!
-Original Message-
From: e. ahmet tonak [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2003 7:41 AM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: G. William Domhoff; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [PEN-L:35855] G. William Domhoff
Title: RE: [PEN-L:35859] Re: RE: G. William Domhoff replies...The whole thing?
I think with the killing of people in Iraq, Palestine,
we don't need
to center on personalities.
That's what I was saying: petty attacks on Domhoff and the like are distractions (at best
I did forward the whole thing. It was just interspersed by my own
comments. I did get another message from him that is not worth
commenting on.
--
The Marxism list: www.marxmail.org
Devine, James wrote:
Instead of being pelted with petty personal attacks, Domhoff should be
given credit for doing excellent research to produce his books.
What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research. Last night I
told my wife that 90 percent of the people on lists like PEN-L and PSN
Please, let's cool it. There are more important things going on now. Do
we really need circular firing squads?
On Fri, Mar 21, 2003 at 12:09:10PM -0500, Louis Proyect wrote:
Doug Henwood wrote:
And who is centering on personalities? Now it's Domhoff, added to a long
list of ad hominems,
Let's everybody chill out. Louis' participation in this latest round has been constructive. We needn't have matters degenerate as they have at times. right now there's a war on. Can everyone here be nice to each other over things that don't matter? Louis has actually beeing trying to do that. As
Now that I have been away from this list for the past two days,
spending some time with the Peace Initiave friends over at
Turkey, look what happened.
Justin,
Apparently your spell did not work.
Could you please give it a second try?
Sabri
PS: By the way, there are many fights going on on
Michael Hoover:
What for? Professors are paid to do excellent research.
whatever gave you above idea?
I have no idea. It just popped into my head like any other outrageous
thought. In any case, here's what a friend of mine, who teaches at a funky
NYC community college and who attended
Domhoff names names in the structure without conceptualizing it adequately.
It's a much more "American" way of going at the issue. At the other extreme,
people conceptualize the structure elaborately but do not name any names.
Though each has its advantages and disadvantages, a blend of both is
Lou,
If it is not too personal, it would be a good idea to forward Domhoff's
entire response. Did you do it already?
Louis Proyect wrote:
Bill Domhoff wrote:
for a Marxist, you don't seem to have much appreciation for
structure, except of course in the economyat least so I gather
12 matches
Mail list logo
