Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Eugene Coyle "Devine, James" wrote: is there really such a thing as an "original idea"? JD Yes, but such can't be revealed on Lists until the patent/ copywrite comes through. Original ideas are intellectual property. Gene === "Before

Re: RE: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Eugene Coyle
  "Devine, James" wrote:   is there really such a thing as an "original idea"? JD Yes, but such can't be revealed on Lists until the patent/ copywrite comes through.  Original ideas are intellectual property. Gene  

Re: Re: RE: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Eugene Coyle To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2002 9:40 AM Subject: [PEN-L:28358] Re: RE: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods "Devine, James" wrote: is there really such a thing as an "original idea"? JD Original id

Re: RE: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Justin Schwartz
> >is there really such a thing as an "original idea"? >JD Ask Michael. I wouldn't know. jks _ Send and receive Hotmail on your mobile device: http://mobile.msn.com

RE: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:28348] Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods > >I am sorry that my initial question on market socialism made Justin > >Schwartz leave the mail group. I didn't want that. > >   > It didn't. I've been busy. I _do_ resent Michael P'

Re: Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread ravi
Justin Schwartz wrote: > > I _do_ resent Michael P's telling to meto > you say tomato, he says tometo, bananas, banahnahs, havanna, havahnah, pater, mater, uncle, aunty; so if you go for scallops and he goes for lobsters, so all right no contest we'll order lobster for we know we need each oth

Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Justin Schwartz
> > >I am sorry that my initial question on market socialism made Justin >Schwartz leave the mail group. I didn't want that. > It didn't. I've been busy. I _do_ resent Michael P's telling to meto shut up because I have nothing new to say, unlike all the other sparklingly original ideas one f

Re: Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-23 Thread Waistline2
Reformism 2 Many of us have learnt a little Lenin. The question of reform versus revolution and Reform or Revolution is posed incorrectly for this phase of the class struggle, meaning on July 23, 2002. World Com went belly up over the weekend and 17 thousand workers are hitting the bricks. CEO's a

Reformism V Revolutionary Methods

2002-07-22 Thread Natasha Potter
I am sorry that my initial question on market socialism made Justin Schwartz leave the mail group. I didn't want that. I have to say I found the discussion on the subject interesting and I may get back with a few more questions when I get through all the posts. The arguments over *reform* ver