Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right? [Response to Marvin]

2007-08-04 Thread Marvin Gandall
Leigh wrote: On 8/2/07, Marvin Gandall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: and it is not the case, in any event, that the least skilled tend to be more advanced in these areas than the most skilled. I wonder whether Leigh would agree. Disagree... More often than not, the least skilled are aware of

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-03 Thread The Buffalo In Da' Midst
On 8/2/07, Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: by the way, let me know when hippies think of themselves, and act as, 'hippies'. No, they often act like hippies. But sometimes they think they aren't hippies. On a tangent, that can also be applied to the question what is a 'worker'... What

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-03 Thread Anthony D'Costa
Raghu hits it right, which paraphrases a brief discussion I wrote last week. There is considerable fuzziness over this. In fact separating the abstract and the concrete connotations of exploitation might be helpful. Many IT professionals from India are also entrepreneurs (who literally

[PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Brian McKenna
A CounterPunch Special Report on the Economy In Richistan: Fantastic Wealth for a Few; Steady Decline for Many The Return of the Robber Barons By PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS The US economy continues its 21st century decline, even as the Bush Regime outfits B-2 stealth bombers with 30,000 pound monster

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Anthony D'Costa
We need some evidence for the following: Meanwhile, US colleges and universities continue to graduate hundreds of thousands of qualified engineers, IT professionals, and other professionals who will never have the opportunity to work in the professions for which they have been trained. America

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread raghu
On 8/2/07, Anthony D'Costa [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We need some evidence for the following: Meanwhile, US colleges and universities continue to graduate hundreds of thousands of qualified engineers, IT professionals, and other professionals who will never have the opportunity to work in the

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread The Buffalo In Da' Midst
On 8/2/07, Anthony D'Costa [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: We need some evidence for the following: Meanwhile, US colleges and universities continue to graduate hundreds of thousands of qualified engineers, IT professionals, and other professionals who will never have the opportunity to work in the

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Carrol Cox
The Buffalo In Da' Midst wrote: I don't feel sorry for the professional bourgeoisie at all. For the most part, their expectations led to their own problems, psychological, sociological, and financial. This belief should make the capitalists happy, since it guarantees disunity in the working

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread The Buffalo In Da' Midst
On 8/2/07, Carrol Cox [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The Buffalo In Da' Midst wrote: I don't feel sorry for the professional bourgeoisie at all. For the most part, their expectations led to their own problems, psychological, sociological, and financial. This belief should make the

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread raghu
On 8/2/07, Carrol Cox [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This belief should make the capitalists happy, since it guarantees disunity in the working class. Carrol Are foreigners on work visas part of the working class? Does setting domestic workers against foreigners not guarantee disunity in the

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread The Buffalo In Da' Midst
On 8/2/07, raghu [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Are foreigners on work visas part of the working class? Does setting domestic workers against foreigners not guarantee disunity in the working class? -raghu. I consider foreign workers on H1b (and other types of) visa as 'self-exploited'

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Jim Devine
Lou Dobbs -- I mean Paul Craig Roberts -- writes that: Another deceit is the measure called core inflation. This measure of inflation excludes food and energy, two large components of the average family's budget. Wall Street and corporations and, therefore, the media emphasize core inflation,

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread raghu
On 8/2/07, The Buffalo In Da' Midst [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I consider foreign workers on H1b (and other types of) visa as 'self-exploited' bourgeoisie. They tolerate their own exploitation for personal gain. Now, look up the word opportunist. Perhaps. But you have to remember most of them

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Carrol Cox
raghu wrote: On 8/2/07, Carrol Cox [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This belief should make the capitalists happy, since it guarantees disunity in the working class. Carrol Are foreigners on work visas part of the working class? Does setting domestic workers against foreigners not guarantee

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Sabri Oncu
Leigh: Let me know when they think of themselves, and act as, 'working class'. Whether they think of themselves as working class is another issue. But they act as working class because they are working class. Working class does not always act to the liking of the progressives. Best, Sabri

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Jim Devine
On 8/2/07, Sabri Oncu [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Leigh: Let me know when they think of themselves, and act as, 'working class'. Sabri: Whether they think of themselves as working class is another issue. But they act as working class because they are working class. Working class does not always

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread raghu
On 8/2/07, Carrol Cox [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The criticism of high-paid workers (who ARE working-class, not part of the bourgeosie) introduces a moralistic element into thinking about class. That is disastrous. Higher wages for already high-pay workers DOES NOT effect in any way the wages or

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Michael Perelman
As I recall, the index shifted to rents when housing prices were rising [during the Reagan Admin?] much faster than rents. It was intended to lower the CPI [perhaps when Roberts was in the Treasury Department] If homeowners make up a majority of the populations, annual payments might make

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Carrol Cox
Marvin Gandall wrote: By the way, downward or upward pressures on pay and benefits on one group of workers do tend to affect other groups. Workers, especially union members, habitually compare their pay movements to others in their workplace and industry, and employers are required to pay

Re: [PEN-L] Does Roberts Get it Right?

2007-08-02 Thread Marvin Gandall
Carrol wrote: Borderline cases tend to corrupt analysis. Management (as I would describe it) is simply part of the capitalist class, their share of surplus value coming to them in the form of salaries. But Management is also a rubber-bag category that can be stretched weirdly. According to a