[RESEND] Re: pdd03 and method calls

2004-01-11 Thread Leopold Toetsch
[ I think this still needs some clarification ] Leopold Toetsch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dan Sugalski [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: At 10:42 PM +0100 12/17/03, Leopold Toetsch wrote: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-22 Thread Leopold Toetsch
Dan Sugalski [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: At 10:42 PM +0100 12/17/03, Leopold Toetsch wrote: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that the method PMC should go into P2. This doesn't really play with Perl5 - Perl6

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-22 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 12:44 PM -0500 12/18/03, Melvin Smith wrote: At 10:42 PM 12/17/2003 +0100, Leopold Toetsch wrote: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that the method PMC should go into P2. This doesn't really play with Perl5 - Perl6

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-22 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 7:38 PM +0100 12/18/03, Juergen Boemmels wrote: Dan Sugalski [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: PDD 03 states that the *object* goes in P2. This works out just fine with perl 5 style method calls, where the argument list doesn't distinguish the object other than by position. What happens is that

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-18 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 10:42 PM +0100 12/17/03, Leopold Toetsch wrote: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that the method PMC should go into P2. This doesn't really play with Perl5 - Perl6 interoperbility IMHO. Perl5 methods are plain

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-18 Thread Juergen Boemmels
Leopold Toetsch [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that the method PMC should go into P2. This doesn't really play with Perl5 - Perl6 interoperbility IMHO. Perl5 methods are plain subs,

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-18 Thread Juergen Boemmels
Dan Sugalski [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: PDD 03 states that the *object* goes in P2. This works out just fine with perl 5 style method calls, where the argument list doesn't distinguish the object other than by position. What happens is that when a perl 5 sub is called, @_ is a combination of

Re: pdd03 and method calls

2003-12-18 Thread Melvin Smith
At 10:42 PM 12/17/2003 +0100, Leopold Toetsch wrote: While playing with calling threaded subs, I came along a thing which I think might be suboptimal: pdd03 states that the method PMC should go into P2. This doesn't really play with Perl5 - Perl6 interoperbility IMHO. Perl5 methods are plain