Re: ftp woes

2003-05-29 Thread Bryan Irvine
editing resolv.conf to not do remote lookups fixed the long login issue. Is there another way? my pass out rules are here: pass out on $WAN inet proto { tcp, udp } all keep state pass out on $WAN inet proto tcp modulate state Wouldn't the top one keep the state with the dns server? Should I

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-29 Thread Trevor Talbot
On Wednesday, May 28, 2003, at 09:39 US/Pacific, Bryan Irvine wrote: editing resolv.conf to not do remote lookups fixed the long login issue. Is there another way? I looked around (quickly) for a way to prevent ftpd from doing the lookups in the first place, but I didn't see anything. Perhaps

ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Bryan Irvine
I'm having problems using an FTP server on a DMZ. I thought initially the problem was with the ftp-proxy, but I've commented out those lines. With still no luck. The relevent parts of the pf.conf file are here. WAN = xl0 DMZ = xl3 LOOPBACK = lo0 LAN1 = xl1 LAN2 = xl2 LANS = { $LAN1 $LAN2 }

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread j knight
Bryan Irvine wrote: I'm having problems using an FTP server on a DMZ. I thought initially the problem was with the ftp-proxy, but I've commented out those lines. With still no luck. You're being way too sparse on details, but I'll take a stab at it. The relevent parts of the pf.conf file are

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Bryan Irvine
I'm trying to get active working. I've been fidgeting with it all day and here's the rulesset that finally got passive to work. # pass in quick on $WAN proto { tcp udp } from any to $FTPServer port { \ ftp ftp-data } keep state pass in

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Bryan Irvine
here what it looks like now. pass in quick on $WAN inet proto tcp from any to $FTPServer port { ftp,\ ftp-data, 1023 } flags S/SA keep state pass in on $WAN inet proto tcp from any to $FTPServer port www keep \ state It pretty much does the same thing...take forever for the login prompt to come

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Bryan Irvine
arrgghh! ok I must be missing something really simple. on to my famous ascii art!! [internet]---[OBSD]---[DMZ with ftp server] -public range no on a NAT / \ / NAT2 (connects fine to ftp server in active mode) NAT1 (also connects just fine in active

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Trevor Talbot
On Tuesday, May 27, 2003, at 14:39 US/Pacific, Bryan Irvine wrote: [internet]---[OBSD]---[DMZ with ftp server] -public range no on a NAT / \ / NAT2 (connects fine to ftp server in active mode) NAT1 (also connects just fine in active mode) Clients on the

Re: ftp woes

2003-05-27 Thread Bryan Irvine
16:02:12.855960 12-213-225-238.client.attbi.com.42840 64-1-201-147.daf.concentric.net.ftp: . ack 1 win 17376 nop,nop,timestamp 901947366 1577248712 (DF) 16:02:12.859376 64-1-201-147.daf.concentric.net.38315 knox2.horvitznewspapers.net.domain: 52301+ PTR? 238.225.213.12.in-addr.arpa. (45) It

Re: Idea about automagic handling of active and passive mode FTP woes

2002-08-07 Thread kjell
I have an idea.. Dunno if anyone else has suggested tried or shot it down previously. I'm not a programmer and as such am not sure if this is even possible with PF. This is the approach ipf took. It is fraught with peril. First, PF operates at the IP layer. To watch for these commands in