Re: [political-research] Re: Can the Jewish Model Help the West Survive (Kevin MacDonald)

2006-12-21 Thread Sean McBride
The bottom line on all of this for me: I think it was a sweet thing when human civilization reached the stage of valuing individualism and meritocracy over tribalism and ethnic nationalism. Would you want to be attacked, persecuted, discriminated against or denied opportunities simply because

Re: [political-research] Re: Can the Jewish Model Help the West Survive (Kevin MacDonald)

2006-12-21 Thread Sean McBride
Let me clarify: I didn't accuse anyone of being a Nazi. What I am saying is: all ethnic nationalist movements usually result in violent conflict with ethnic outsiders -- that is the essential dynamic of ethnic nationalism in general. It's difficult for me to imagine any Euro-centric

[political-research] Re: Can the Jewish Model Help the West Survive (Kevin MacDonald)

2006-12-20 Thread tim_howells_1000
Sean McBride wrote: By the way, I doubt that an explosion of European ethnic nationalism is an effective way to deal with the problems that Haim Saban and Avigdor Lieberman pose for Europe and the United States. It's difficult to see much of a future for ethnic nationalism as an organizing

Re: [political-research] Re: Can the Jewish Model Help the West Survive (Kevin MacDonald)

2006-12-20 Thread Sean McBride
European ethnic nationalism made a major play in the 20th century and it was called Nazism -- correct? And that ended not so prettily? I am trying to imagine scenarios in which a European ethnic nationalist movement results in a positive or successful outcome -- I am having no success.