Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-09 Thread Victor Tsaran
Hi Slau. Thanks a lot for such a comprehensive answer. This is pretty much what I was looking for. Logic will remain for me a kind of an instrument to play with, but I am looking to get back into some editing and this is why I asked the question. Thanks again. Vic On Tuesday, February 6, 2018

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-07 Thread Krister Ekstrom
Yes indeed i have Komplete as well albeit only a Mk1. /Krister > 7 feb. 2018 kl. 18:07 skrev Ricky Prevatte : > > Chi that is exactly what I am doing now using logic as a supplement. Most of > my work little of It there is is done in Protools. Christer you would not

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-07 Thread Ricky Prevatte
Chi that is exactly what I am doing now using logic as a supplement. Most of my work little of It there is is done in Protools. Christer you would not have to have a control surface you would enjoy I believe working with Protools doing your audio and you of course still have logic. Do you not

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-07 Thread Chi Kim
Hi All, Interesting thread! First, let me clarify some of the things mentioned about me. My main DAW is Logic as Slau mentioned. I'm forced to use Logic because my main collaborators use Logic. I also developed Flogic which is no where close to Flo Tools yet. Having said that, I mainly teach

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Slau Halatyn
A surface was never mandatory except, perhaps, back in Pro Tools version 5.x when the faders were not visible in the Mix window. At that time, a surface was pretty much an absolute necessity. A surface is not required for the current state of things. That said, I can't imagine doing a proper

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Krister Ekstrom
Ok, have to find out about licensing options in Avid. I have no studio as such, i’m an amateur making productions in my living room so i have no clients as such, so time isn’t necessarily of the esance because i would think that an Avid control surface is quite a costly business, so can i

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Ricky Prevatte
Well I will first clarify that I am not an expert on ProTools or logic. But when I start a project I intend to finish it I also intend to have a fairly simple work flow. The answer for me is Protools I have been a Windows user: those days are over. I am a logic user but I detest the drilling

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Slau Halatyn
The many options in terms of annual upgrade and subscription plan depends on which version and which type of Pro Tools license one has to begin with. If starting from scratch, there's an initial charge of something like $300 or so and then it's $99 per year. If you let that expire, you'll have

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Krister Ekstrom
So have i misunderstood things correctly, :-) Even if i am an earlier protools user, the cost for v2018.1 is $399 for the first year? What surfaces are recommended nowadays, is it only the Avid line if you want to have full benefit of it? /Krister > 6 feb. 2018 kl. 19:00 skrev Slau Halatyn

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Slau Halatyn
Things have changed enormously since version 11 so, yes, you missed a lot. The annual subscription for Pro Tools is $99 per year with an initial cost of $300 for the first year with a support contract. Logic does have great built-in sounds but it offers the same in terms of manuals and there's

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Krister Ekstrom
That is exactly the reason why i leftt Pro tools, the fact that you were almost forced to have a control surface to do most of the work quickly and not only that, if you were going to have a control surface where you didn’t have to learn and assign all the parameters yourself, you *had* to have

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Slau Halatyn
e in lies > the problem for any of us who work in multiple DAW’s. > > From: ptaccess@googlegroups.com [mailto:ptaccess@googlegroups.com] On Behalf > Of Slau Halatyn > Sent: 06 February 2018 15:20 > To: PTAccess List > Subject: Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and pro

RE: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Phil Muir
. _ From: ptaccess@googlegroups.com [mailto:ptaccess@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Slau Halatyn Sent: 06 February 2018 15:20 To: PTAccess List Subject: Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity Hi Victor, I believe that the only person truly qualified to give the fullest

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Slau Halatyn
Hi Victor, I believe that the only person truly qualified to give the fullest answer to this question is Chi Kim. Chi's primary DAW for years has been Logic. However, Chi has also been a Windows user and is familiar with the offerings on that side of the fence. More important, he's quite well

RE: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Phil Muir
@googlegroups.com [mailto:ptaccess@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Victor Tsaran Sent: 06 February 2018 06:25 To: Pro Tools Accessibility Subject: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity Hello all! Please please no flame wars! I would really like to hear from expert users who used

Re: Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-06 Thread Jean-Philippe Rykiel
Hi Vic, Interesting. I'd like to get the opinion from folks who are using audio and MIDI together. Best, JPR http://www.jprykiel.com http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet http://twitter.com/ryksounet http://facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel Le 06/02/2018 à 07:25, Victor Tsaran a écrit : Hello

Protools vs Logic Pro, accessibility and productivity

2018-02-05 Thread Victor Tsaran
Hello all! Please please no flame wars! I would really like to hear from expert users who used both Logic and Protools with VoiceOver on Mac OS. To be more precise, I mean the Flotools/Protools combination vs Flogic/Logic one. After reading various release notes on Flotools.org, I came to