RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-29 Thread Gabriel Cosentino de Barros
Title: RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? From: Paul Rubin [mailto:http://phr.cx@NOSPAM.invalid] This still seems way too complicated. Why execute a bunch of separate statements when what you're trying to set up is a single structure? IMHO, i think that the code to create

RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-29 Thread Gabriel Cosentino de Barros
Title: RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? But even then, if DaBo ever becomes as easy to use as Delphi/VB for this type of applications, while remaining cross-platform, that might easily double the number of Python developers. ;-) VB/delphi are ridiculous. dont' aim

RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-29 Thread Gabriel Cosentino de Barros
Title: RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? - speed where it matters (ie. no 20s load time) Load what? The app, or the data? Users don't care how long the app takes to start up, since they usually run it all day long. Data response is a whole 'nother matter, and Dabo

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-29 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 29, 2004, at 1:06 PM, Gabriel Cosentino de Barros wrote: So, to be more direct: If you create one app that opens one window with one button in wxWindow and exit (exit, so that 'time' can canculate it for you), and then the same thing in Dabo, what's the time diference? I used the timeit

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 27, 2004, at 5:01 PM, JanC wrote: IMHO this is the worst think for the Python community: you can find one Python only with an excellent support. Great But on the other hand it is possible to find plenty of GUI tools and for the beginner (and may be not just for the beginner) it is so

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Paul Rubin
Ed Leafe [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Here's the equivalent in Dabo: menu = dabo.ui.dMenu() itm = menu.append(Close Window, self, self.onCloseWindow) This still seems way too complicated. Why execute a bunch of separate statements when what you're trying to set up is a single structure? E.g.:

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Paul Rubin
Ed Leafe [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Oh, geez. After months of us getting skewered for releasing Dabo under GPL, with everyone saying that they wouldn't even *look* at it for fear of 'infecting' all of their code, we change the license to the MIT license, and now the complaint is that

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 28, 2004, at 1:16 PM, Paul Rubin wrote: Well, those are commercial developers who are afraid of the GPL. No, they were several members of the Python community. I disagreed with their interpretation of the GPL, but the fact remains that it was a major stumbling block to getting others

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread JanC
Ed Leafe schreef: I think the field of GUI frameworks / tools for Python is fragmented because it's fragmented outside of Python too... I think that the reason things are fragmented in this field is that none of the tools are simple enough to learn. Even on Windows, where several

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 28, 2004, at 5:52 PM, JanC wrote: But even then, if DaBo ever becomes as easy to use as Delphi/VB for this type of applications, while remaining cross-platform, that might easily double the number of Python developers. ;-) Well, there are at least a half-million Visual FoxPro developers

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-28 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 28, 2004, at 9:04 PM, Luke Skywalker wrote: Interesting discussion. I haven't looked at Dabo yet, but the issues that must be solved before Python is a valid alternative to proprietary solutions like Delphi or VB are: - speed where it matters (ie. no 20s load time) Load what? The app, or

RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-27 Thread Gabriel Cosentino de Barros
Title: RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? From: Paul Rubin [mailto:http://phr.cx@NOSPAM.invalid] Dave Cook [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: You might not care. And in that case Tk is much simpler than just about anything else, unless looks are really important. I've used

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-27 Thread JanC
McBooCzech schreef: IMHO this is the worst think for the Python community: you can find one Python only with an excellent support. Great But on the other hand it is possible to find plenty of GUI tools and for the beginner (and may be not just for the beginner) it is so hard to choose the

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-25 Thread McBooCzech
Sorry to bother, but I didn't find the final answer to the question what is the Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? I am the newbie in Python, so I am trying to find some usable GUI as well. But it looks to me there is a lot developers, beta-versions, tools etc. I have spent a lot of time

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-25 Thread Paul Rubin
McBooCzech [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I am the newbie in Python, so I am trying to find some usable GUI as well. But it looks to me there is a lot developers, beta-versions, tools etc. I have spent a lot of time trying to find which is the best one tool. But now it looks more confusing to me

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-23 Thread Steve Holden
huy wrote: Dave Cook wrote: On 2004-12-20, Paul Rubin http wrote: I think I can put together a useable (but not visually stunning) web interface faster than I can put together any pure client-side interface. Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You don't even have something

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-23 Thread Dave Cook
On 2004-12-21, Paul Rubin http wrote: Dave Cook [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You might not care. And in that case Tk is much simpler than just about anything else, unless looks are really important. You don't even have something as

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-23 Thread Al Christians
Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You don't even have something as simple as a combo box (i.e. an editable entry with a drop down), let alone the rich set of widgets something like wxwidgets offers. Also web development doesn't seem as coherent to me as development with a

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-22 Thread kdahlhaus
ZOPE could provide the workaround but ZOPE seems really huge to me and an overkill for this. Or maybe it would work? I am intenionally *not* trying to argue web vs traditional gui for your app, but to tuck away for future apps, CherryPy2 is a lot easier than Zope to use and programming it does

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-22 Thread huy
Dave Cook wrote: On 2004-12-20, Paul Rubin http wrote: I think I can put together a useable (but not visually stunning) web interface faster than I can put together any pure client-side interface. Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You don't even have something as simple

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Phil Thompson
I admit that I don't know much about Qt in Windows. As, I said, I've never seen it. The fact that they don't offer a GPLed version for Windows is a deterrent for me. I have heard very nice things about Qt's api. I even bought a book on it, but since the apps I've needed to write, had to

wxPython documentation [was: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?]

2004-12-21 Thread Richie Hindle
[Gerhard, quoting a blog] wxPython doesn't seem bad, but it lacks any documentation I see this a lot, and it baffles me. wxPython is a thin wrapper over wxWidgets, which is very well documented. Where they differ, the wxWidgets documentation discusses those differences. Add the excellent

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Dave Cook
On 2004-12-20, Bulba! [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'll soon start development of a specialized small app and need to choose GUI for it. I've had success with pygtk on win32 and Linux (and OS X with the X11 server installed.) http://www.pcpm.ucl.ac.be/~gustin/win32_ports/

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Dave Cook
On 2004-12-20, Paul Rubin http wrote: I think I can put together a useable (but not visually stunning) web interface faster than I can put together any pure client-side interface. Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You don't even have something as simple as a combo box

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 20, 2004, at 7:25 AM, Bulba! wrote: The long lists of invoices, subcontractors and tasks (possibly hundreds or thousands) will have to be displayed - which toolkit is better for that in your experience? I would appreciate anybody sharing their experiences with relevant toolkits in

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Jarek Zgoda
Bulba! wrote: - QT seems to be industrial-strength, but.. it's probably more complex/difficult to use. - wxPython/PythonCard is probably simple to use, but.. are there not some pitfalls that development will fall into once the app starts growing (they all do)? From my point of view, PyQt is

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Paul Rubin
Dave Cook [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Web browser widgets seem pretty limited to me, though. You might not care. You don't even have something as simple as a combo box (i.e. an editable entry with a drop down), Just put an input field and a dropdown on the page. let alone the rich set of

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Bulba!
On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 16:20:48 -0500, Ed Leafe [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: You might want to check out Dabo, an application framework of which I am one of the authors. We use wxPython as our UI toolkit, but have streamlined the programming of the UI. We've also added data binding, making

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-21 Thread Ed Leafe
On Dec 21, 2004, at 7:42 PM, Bulba! wrote: This advice of yours (thanks) may have slashdotted your site by flood of requests from Python programmers all looking at your website. ;-) Proxy Error The proxy server received an invalid response from an upstream server. The proxy server could not handle

Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Bulba!
I'll soon start development of a specialized small app and need to choose GUI for it. I have narrowed the choice to wxPython/PythonCard and QT/PyQT (buying commercial licenses is not a big problem, the company would pay for it). Which is better for this kind of application? I mean, looking

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Steve Holden
Paul Rubin wrote: Bulba! [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I'll soon start development of a specialized small app and need to choose GUI for it. I have narrowed the choice to wxPython/PythonCard and QT/PyQT What does the app need to do? I'd try to make it web based unless there's a good reason not

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Bulba!
On 20 Dec 2004 04:43:06 -0800, Paul Rubin http://[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'll soon start development of a specialized small app and need to choose GUI for it. I have narrowed the choice to wxPython/PythonCard and QT/PyQT What does the app need to do? Basically, it's for a data-entry

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Steve Holden [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: What does the app need to do? I'd try to make it web based unless there's a good reason not to. That's even if it just runs on the user's desktop; run the http listener on the localhost and let the user connect to it with a browser. I'm not sure

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Bulba! [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Reason 1: It would be somewhat complex to develop it using PHP (I have done some recon in that area) and using GUI on Windows is actually faster way of entering and editing data than via the Web browser I think. Well, I was concentrating more on

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread RM
Here is another question, are you deploying in Linux, Windows, Mac, or some combination of these? I think that may be a big factor to consider. I do like the look of Qt under Linux, however, I have never seen it under Windows. Qt seems to be very focused in Linux, with Mac and Windows support

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Phil Thompson
Here is another question, are you deploying in Linux, Windows, Mac, or some combination of these? I think that may be a big factor to consider. I do like the look of Qt under Linux, however, I have never seen it under Windows. Qt seems to be very focused in Linux, with Mac and Windows

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Paul Rubin
Bulba! [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Your CherryPy powered web applications are in fact stand-alone Python applications embedding their own web server. You can deploy them anywhere you can run Python applications. - cool!! You might not really want a separate socket listener for each application.

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread RM
Bulba! wrote: Hmm.. and if I may ask, what limitations you have stumbled on? In reality, PythonCard is just an easier way of manipulating wxPython. The thing is that PythonCard needs to have a wraper for each wxPython widget that it uses, and, then that wrapper needs to be incorporated into

RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Gabriel Cosentino de Barros
Title: RE: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app? ( sorry about top posting) 1. Ever avoid web based. unless you have to do it webbased. I've been doing web based apps for 5 years now. it simple don't pay off! usability within a browser sucks, unless you can spend time re-writting

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread RM
I admit that I don't know much about Qt in Windows. As, I said, I've never seen it. The fact that they don't offer a GPLed version for Windows is a deterrent for me. I have heard very nice things about Qt's api. I even bought a book on it, but since the apps I've needed to write, had to be

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Diez B. Roggisch
Question for you, does Qt use the native Windows dialogs and widgets or does it use its own? If the latter, how close are they to the native look? Will they change appearance when a user chooses a different theme in the Display Dialog? AFAIK they do all stuff themselves. And also AFAIK

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Kevin Walzer
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Diez B. Roggisch wrote: |Question for you, does Qt use the native Windows dialogs and widgets or |does it use its own? If the latter, how close are they to the native |look? Will they change appearance when a user chooses a different |theme in the

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread John Machin
Thomas Heller wrote: Bulba! [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I'll soon start development of a specialized small app and need to choose GUI for it. Quoting a somewhat popular german blogger, on the state of cross platform Python GUI toolkits (http://blog.schockwellenreiter.de/7282): [snip]

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread Luke Skywalker
On 20 Dec 2004 13:28:02 -0800, John Machin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Babelfish gave up on durchzuwursteln and so did I -- through-to-sausage-??? This is getting erotic ;-) Luke. -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Re: Best GUI for small-scale accounting app?

2004-12-20 Thread tfillmor
Personally I think the priority of all new project developmnent should be based principally on web technologies, with OS-specific (i.e., desktop) versions only if there is absolutely no other way. You should really try CherryPy (http://www.cherrypy.org) - for Python-based web development I don't