Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread erland
Philip Meyer;548506 Wrote: It's getting painfully obvious that it gets too complex to reliably include anything that's dependent on the network or a server when triggering the alarm in the Radio. I don't know why that should be the case - my SB3 alarm works reliably, and that should be less

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread erland
bluegaspode;548509 Wrote: I miss: - (for the start) fadein of the mp3 . Agreed, that should definitely be included bluegaspode;548509 Wrote: - (for the second release) I'm a Radio fan. I didn't want to wakeup to the same tune every day. Which means you had to support starting a

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread Mnyb
Philip Meyer;548506 Wrote: It's getting painfully obvious that it gets too complex to reliably include anything that's dependent on the network or a server when triggering the alarm in the Radio. I don't know why that should be the case - my SB3 alarm works reliably, and that should be less

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread bluegaspode
erland;548517 Wrote: I just know that my Radio wakes me up with normal music every morning and almost gives me a heart attack a number of minutes later when my nice music is replaces by the fallback alarm. By looking in the logs it seems like it's caused by short temporary network problem. I

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread toby10
Great idea erland. Getting a simple function back to... simple. Couple of suggestions: - small selection of basic Alarm sounds to choose from (bells, chimes, siren, voice recording of my mother-in-law) - pressing Play dismisses the Alarm, plays the last item played - pressing a Preset

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread peterw
To your feature list I'd add the ability to set a different alarm for each day of the week (I disagree with bluegaspode on that, obviously). I don't think you need the ability to set N arbitrary alarms, but I do think it would be nice to try to accommodate users who don't wake up the same time

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread snarlydwarf
erland;548517 Wrote: I'm not sure I want to add things like this, it will make it too complex. Sending WOL to the server should be ok, but just to make sure it's alive when you turn off the alarm and selects to continue playing your radio favorite/preset instead. What is the lead-time on

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-18 Thread Marc
Don't forget that there would still be prospective problems even with a totally localized alarm application. Without the proper synchronization between local (Radio based) apps and server requests the playout subsystem may well end up fought over (which is what sometimes happens today with the

[SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-17 Thread erland
It's getting painfully obvious that it gets too complex to reliably include anything that's dependent on the network or a server when triggering the alarm in the Radio. I'm sure it's possible to do but probably not within a reasonable time/cost with the limited number of development resources

Re: [SlimDevices: Radio] Local reliable alarm, what would be acceptable ?

2010-05-17 Thread Mnyb
But if the user is instructed to simply don't configure any alarms on the server(s). If you do a completely independent simple alarm applet The only conflict I see is that it tries to fire to many alarms your proposed applet and the built in alarm (if configured). Giving you not only a heart