Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread Brendan Willard
This is a very thorough look at wide range 1x11, covers most combinations across a broad price range, though it is indeed focused on wide range... https://bikepacking.com/gear/wide-range-1x11/ Pathlesspedaled has a lot of useful info too. Best, Brendan Speaking in Thumbs  > On May 16,

Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread Brendan Willard
Any Shimano 11 speed medium cage with a microshift bar end BS-m11-R will work well. Speaking in Thumbs  > On May 16, 2020, at 7:48 PM, William deRosset wrote: > > Dear Robert, > > Re: brand choices for 1x gears with a bar-end shifter: SRAM Force 1 and > matching indexed bar end. > > It

[RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread William deRosset
Dear Robert, Re: brand choices for 1x gears with a bar-end shifter: SRAM Force 1 and matching indexed bar end. It has a wide-range clutch rear derailleur designed specifically for a no front derailleur condition. I use the integrated lever version, and it works well. The derailleur looks

[RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread William deRosset
Dear RG, Also, I assume you are a member of the DC randonneurs group. They're super helpful and can really dial in your needs well, as they're on the scene, doing what you do. My time in VA was in SW VA, and I remember short, steep walls and legbreakers a'plenty.. Best Regards, Will William

[RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread William deRosset
Dear RG, What do you use now? Is the low low enough? Do you never spin out the high? If so, then you have bounded your needs. Work out the gear range of that setup (ignoring whatever gears you never use), using your wheel size. Then you can transfer that range to the 1x setup by assigning the

Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-16 Thread Patrick Moore
Understood; each to his own. It's just that for non-hilly terrain I personally would like close ratios in the middle and would give up a very low climbing gear. FWIW, I set up my Matthews dirt road bike with a very close ratio (13-25) 1X10 with an added very occasional granny (28) for lowish

Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-15 Thread Wyatt
Patrick, the benefit of running a wide range cassette on a road bike is pretty straightforward. You get all of the plusses of a 1x drivetrain (if you like that sort of thing) and can still run a big chainring up front (think 44t or even larger) without losing a decent climbing/bailout gear.

Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-14 Thread Patrick Moore
BTW, I will not criticize anyone who wants to put a 32 X 10-50 on a road bike; do whatever is the most fun. I certainly have some weird drivetrains. But I thought someone ought to point out that perhaps you don't need such a high high or low low for such a bike, and that you might want smaller

Re: [RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-14 Thread Patrick Moore
I'm curious why you need a 46 or 42 t cog on a bike built to be a fast road bike, especially in DC (I lived and rode there). I would think you'd sorely miss closer ratios in the middle gears, no? The first 11 sp cassette meant for a single ring that I could find was this one for a 42 t ring:

[RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-14 Thread Wyatt
Can’t say I know the best, but I recently set up a 1x11 drive train with a Microshift bar end, SLX rear derailleur, and SLX 11-46 rear cassette. Loved it, especially once I got the hang of running it friction and doing smooth double or triple shifts. Plenty of range, though I’d probably run a

[RBW] Best 1 - 11 setup

2020-05-14 Thread Robert Gardner
Hi folks -- I am retooling my drive train on my Roadini -- this will be my "fast bike" and potentially used in whatever we are calling rando rides these days (pending any actual group rides happening again). Looking for suggestions on a 1-11 drivetrain -- 11-46? 11-42? I'm in DC, so will be