Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-26 Thread Andrew Newton
On Fri, Jul 26, 2019 at 4:06 AM Gavin Brown wrote: > > On 25 Jul 2019, at 22:43, Andrew Newton wrote: > > In other words, who is NOT doing RDAP because of jCard? Are there any > > registries willing to step up and say they'll deploy RDAP if we move > > to JSContact? > > I'm not too concerned abou

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-26 Thread Andrew Newton
; > > > Thanks > > Roger > > > > > > -Original Message- > From: regext On Behalf Of Andrew Newton > Sent: Thursday, July 25, 2019 4:43 PM > To: Marc Blanchet > Cc: regext > Subject: Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration > > > >

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-26 Thread Gavin Brown
On 25 Jul 2019, at 22:43, Andrew Newton wrote: > In other words, who is NOT doing RDAP because of jCard? Are there any > registries willing to step up and say they'll deploy RDAP if we move > to JSContact? I'm not too concerned about jCard as a barrier to server deployment. I'm more concerned ab

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-25 Thread Roger D Carney
ood for thought. Thanks Roger -Original Message- From: regext On Behalf Of Andrew Newton Sent: Thursday, July 25, 2019 4:43 PM To: Marc Blanchet Cc: regext Subject: Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration Notice: This email is from an external sender. Thanks for des

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-25 Thread Marc Blanchet
Mario, your proposals are another interesting alternatives. thanks! My conclusion is then that there are multiple ways to handle a smooth transition to a new card format. Therefore, I think we should put migration aside as an issue causing to not work on a new card format. If we find a new c

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-25 Thread Mario Loffredo
Hi Marc and Andy, I would like to propose another possible transition model. The model is based on the use of the rdapConformance array values and ad-hoc parameters in the query string. Each RDAP server can work at ant time according to only one of the following two configurations: 1) This co

Re: [regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-25 Thread Andrew Newton
Thanks for describing that. I think that makes sense, and if we have to transition this plan seems like the way to go. Given that there are many registries and clients whom have already implemented jCard, does moving to JSContact mean hold-outs will implement RDAP? In other words, who is NOT doing

[regext] on jcard and jscontact migration

2019-07-25 Thread Marc Blanchet
There has been discussion on replacement of jcard. One of the considerations in the equation is how to handle the migration. Some people have (appropriatly) expressed concerns about this issue of migration. While I’m not yet sure if we need to deprecate jcard, I would like to suggest a way to m