[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-25 Thread Mislav Marohnić
On Jan 25, 2008 9:22 PM, Michael Koziarski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I'm happy with the documentation but not sure I buy the need for > #8720? Why match the API of polymorphic_path with polymorphic_url? Because there is no need for these two to have different signatures, especially since ge

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-25 Thread Michael Koziarski
> OK, so we're keeping formatted_foo helpers for now. But what of my patch? > > http://dev.rubyonrails.org/ticket/10883 > > It fixes issues. It adds tons of documentation. It provides more test > coverage. Is there anything wrong with it? Anything that someone would like > to put up for discussion

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-25 Thread Mislav Marohnić
OK, so we're keeping formatted_foo helpers for now. But what of my patch? http://dev.rubyonrails.org/ticket/10883 It fixes issues. It adds tons of documentation. It provides more test coverage. Is there anything wrong with it? Anything that someone would like to put up for discussion, or to have m

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-24 Thread Michael Koziarski
> I've often wondered why (apart from specific implementation reasons) we need > a formatted_xxx helper to cater for formats at all. I don't believe there's a reason beyond the (considerable) implementation specific reasons :). Changing that with the current routing implementation would probabl

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-22 Thread Chris Cruft
I'm frequently in need of generating a formatted polymorphic url. Currently, it's done ugly because the formatted_polymorphic_url code is broken (see ticket 8782 and Mislav's #2 above). I would like to see that helper working-but if the job can be done with something simpler, I'm all for it. Tre

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-21 Thread Trevor Squires
On 1/21/08, Michael Koziarski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On Jan 22, 2008 9:28 AM, Mislav Marohnić <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > > Should this work: polymorphic_url(@article, :format => :pdf) ? Currently > it > > doesn't. I've included a failing tests, it's commented out.OpenActionPack > >

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-21 Thread Mislav Marohnić
2008/1/22 Michael Koziarski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > What's still broken? (I decided not to fix everything in one go.) > > Hash argument: polymorphic_url(:id => @article). Test is commented out > (like > > before). > > Should this work: polymorphic_url(@article, :format => :pdf) ? Currently > it >

[Rails-core] Re: Polymorphic URL helpers documentation and fixes

2008-01-21 Thread Michael Koziarski
On Jan 22, 2008 9:28 AM, Mislav Marohnić <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Yesterday I answered a question regarding polymorphic URL helpers on Core ML > and noticed that the module has no documentation. I've documented it and > rewritten unit tests using Mocha. I also optimized some of the code slightl