Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-04-03 Thread Brad Wetmore
Looks good. Be sure to check in the closed version when you get your changes finished. Also, check to see if anyone else will be checking in signed jar files. I should have a changeset coming within the next week or so. Thanks, Brad On 4/3/2013 4:31 PM, Anthony Scarpino wrote: Updated

Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-04-03 Thread Anthony Scarpino
Updated code review with regression test. http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mullan/webrevs/ascarpin/8001596/webrev.02/ Tony

Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-03-28 Thread Brad Wetmore
Minor typos that don't affect program execution (comments/javadoc) are ok to not do unit tests, but even through this is a typo, I think this still needs a test. Brad On 3/28/2013 2:51 PM, Anthony Scarpino wrote: I had left the regression test out of this as it was a typo rather than a code

Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-03-28 Thread Anthony Scarpino
I had left the regression test out of this as it was a typo rather than a code logic issue or something someone could rebroken. Are you ok if this goes back without a test? Tony On 03/28/2013 02:46 PM, Brad Wetmore wrote: There is no regression test. I created one which relies on reflection

Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-03-28 Thread Brad Wetmore
There is no regression test. I created one which relies on reflection, which is one way to test this problem. Feel free to create another, but that one is ready to go. Please see the attachment in the bug, and you'll probably want to update the copyright date. Brad On 3/28/2013 2:29 PM,

Re: simple code review request: 8001596

2013-03-28 Thread Brad Wetmore
Just realized, there are no regression tests here. Simplest is to probably do as much setup as you can, then java.security.Security.removeProvider("SunJCE"), then issue the calls that call into these changes. They should all pass in the new version, and fail in the old. Brad On 3/28/2013

simple code review request: 8001596

2013-03-28 Thread Anthony Scarpino
Hi all, I have a very simple code review request. It's a typo bug. 8001596 Incorrect condition check in PBKDF2KeyImpl.JAVA https://jbs.oracle.com/bugs/browse/JDK-8001596 http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mullan/webrevs/ascarpin/8001596/webrev.01/ thanks Tony